Promoting soil functioning by maintaining soil microbial diversity and activity is central for sustainable agriculture. In viticulture, soil management often includes tillage, which poses a multifaceted disturbance to the soil environment and has direct and indirect effects on soil microbial diversity and soil functioning. However, the challenge of disentangling the effects of different soil management practices on soil microbial diversity and functioning has rarely been addressed. In this study, we investigated the effects of soil management on soil bacterial and fungal diversity as well as soil functions (soil respiration and decomposition) using a balanced experimental design with four soil management types in nine vineyards in Germany. Application of structural equation modelling enabled us to investigate the causal relationships of soil disturbance, vegetation cover, and plant richness on soil properties, microbial diversity, and soil functions. We could show that soil disturbance by tillage increased bacterial diversity but decreased fungal diversity. We identified a positive effect of plant diversity on bacterial diversity. Soil respiration showed a positive response to soil disturbance, while decomposition was negatively affected in highly disturbed soils via mediated effects of vegetation removal. Our results contribute to the understanding of direct and indirect effects of vineyard soil management on soil life and aids designing targeted recommendations for agricultural soil management.
Soil tillage or herbicide applications are commonly used in agriculture for weed control. These measures may also represent a disturbance for soil microbial communities and their functions. However, the generality of response patterns of microbial communities and functions to disturbance have rarely been studied at large geographical scales. We investigated how a soil disturbance gradient (low, intermediate, high), realized by either tillage or herbicide application, affects diversity and composition of soil bacterial and fungal communities as well as soil functions in vineyards across five European countries. Microbial alpha-diversity metrics responded to soil disturbance sporadically, but inconsistently across countries. Increasing soil disturbance changed soil microbial community composition at the European level. However, the effects of soil disturbance on the variation of microbial communities were smaller compared to the effects of location and soil covariates. Microbial respiration was consistently impaired by soil disturbance, while effects on decomposition of organic substrates were inconsistent and showed positive and negative responses depending on the respective country. Therefore, we conclude that it is difficult to extrapolate results from one locality to others because microbial communities and environmental conditions vary strongly over larger geographical scales.
Farmland biodiversity and associated ecosystem services are threatened by the expansion and intensification of agriculture. Despite substantial efforts, European conservation policies have largely failed to halt or reverse the decline of farmland biodiversity. To address the pressures associated with agricultural intensification more effectively, conservation measures - such as agri-environmental schemes – need to be tailored based on spatially explicit land system classifications that reflect the interdependencies between agricultural land use and biodiversity. In this study, we present a spatially explicit typology of agricultural land systems in Germany offering a meaningful generalization of the country’s agricultural landscapes to inform and support the tailoring of agri-environmental schemes. We applied a cluster analysis based on indicators of land cover, landscape structure, land-use intensity of different production systems, as well as biophysical indicators, such as climate and topography. Experts from agriculture, conservation, and administration sectors contributed to refining both the indicator selection and the clustering results. Clustering revealed eight distinct agricultural land system types in Germany, including arable cash crop-dominated, animal husbandry-dominated, and mosaic land-use agricultural land system types. Each type represents a characteristic combination of indicators, offering key insights into the specific pressures affecting farmland biodiversity. Drawing on this typology, we discuss entry points for tailoring agri-environmental schemes to reduce land system-specific pressures on biodiversity. This typology has the potential to increase the ecological effectiveness of agri-environmental schemes by tailoring them to land system-specific pressures. Moreover, the methodological approach can be adapted to other countries or scaled beyond the national level.