2 October 2021 in Roeper Review
The field of gifted education, historically and contemporarily, is not well-known for being equitable for underrepresented students, specifically, Black, Hispanic, Native American, among others. In this article, we present a short history of gifted education with attention to key historical figures who have significantly shaped the field; their influence continues to impact theories and measurement to this very day. We share our reservations, along with 10 assumptions that we believe need to be countered. Given the long history of tension in the field regarding issues of racism, ethnocentrism, and classism, we offer perspectives for moving forward proactively and equitably.
1 January 2003 in Theory Into Practice
Few school districts in the United States have successfully recruited and retained culturally diverse students in programs for gifted students. Black, Hispanic, and Native American students are underrepresented in gifted education programs nationally, with underrepresentation ranging from 50-70%. This article addresses two questions that are at least as old as gifted education itself: Why are diverse students underrepresented, and how can we recruit and retain more diverse students in our gifted programs? Factors contributing to the persistent underrepresentation of Black students in gifted education are presented, along with suggestions for changes. The central premise of this article is that deficit thinking held by educators about diverse students hinders access to gifted programs for them.
31 July 2023 in Gifted Child Today
Acceleration is an effective approach for many high ability students, and it can be especially beneficial for Black students. Upstander teachers are those who recognize educational crises and the problem of overlooked and underdeveloped gifts and talents of Black students in regular and gifted education programs. They proactively identify Black students’ intellectual and academic strengths and plan not only enrichment services, but accelerated pathways for Black students to be appropriately challenged. Too many Black students with gifts and talents succumb to boredom, underachievement, and atrophy when bystander teachers have low academic expectations of them and fail to recommend them for academically rigorous advanced and accelerated learning experiences. The purpose of this article is to present acceleration as a means of creating equitable opportunities in gifted education for gifted Black students using Frasier’s Four A’s framework: attitude, access, assessment, and accommodation. Specifically, the following questions are addressed: What are upstander attitudes toward acceleration and related policies? How can upstander teachers know if a Black student is a good candidate for acceleration and increase their access to acceleration? How can upstander teachers provide equitable assessments of Black students for acceleration? What can upstander teachers do to support acceleration programming that accommodates the needs of gifted Black students? Six tables provide an overview of acceleration types, a guide to promote equitable acceleration, and considerations for accelerating gifted Black students.
2 January 2021 in Roeper Review
Tarek C. Grantham, PhD, is Professor of educational psychology at the University of Georgia. He serves as Coordinator for the Gifted and Creative Education Graduate Program, and he co-directs the U...
8 August 2026 in Journal of Advanced Academics
Empirical research consistently documents the persistent underrepresentation of Black students in gifted education, prompting this investigation of racial equity in Georgia's gifted programs. Data were collected from the Office for Civil Rights (2017–2018) across the state's five largest school districts. Using descriptive statistics and Ford's 20% equity allowance index, this study assessed equitable representation by race, focusing primarily on Black students and secondarily on Latine representation to contextualize broader racial disproportionalities. Gender disparities among Black students were also examined. Findings revealed underrepresentation of Black and Latine students, with Black females identified more frequently than Black males. Guided by Expectancy-Value Theory in the development of Degrees of Equity Grading Scale, the study introduces a practitioner-oriented framework to evaluate proportional representation and monitor district-level equity outcomes. By examining intersecting racial and gender patterns, the study offers a strategic tool for assessing and addressing long-standing disparities in gifted education, emphasizing equity as a cornerstone of academic opportunity.