Coal mining will lead to rock strata bending deformation and the redistribution of stress field. The change of principal stress magnitude and direction will influence the failure zone distribution of the coal pillar, which determines the stability and safety of roadway near goaf. In this paper, a theoretical model is established to analyze the rotation of principal stress in the coal pillar caused by the bending deformation of key strata due to coal mining. The theoretical principal stress magnitude and direction in the coal pillar are obtained and the variation of principal stress are analyzed with different coal pillar widths and different roof breaking locations. Furthermore, we derived a novel plastic zone distribution in the coal pillar, which considering mining induced principal stress rotation. The plastic zone in the coal pillar presents the trapezoidal shape with a curved waist, which is different from traditional rectangular plastic zone. This also reveals the mechanism of the upper part of the coal pillar is more prone to become instability and present large deformations. Additionally, a numerical model is established based on the geological conditions of Lingdong coal mine, which is used to verify the theoretical model. The numerical simulation of the stress rotation trend is consistent with the theoretical analysis results. The numerical plastic zone in coal pillar presents a curved waist trapezoidal shape, which match well with the onsite deformation of coal pillar. To a certain extent, this verifies the rationality of the theoretical model.