Although BioMaking is flourishing as a Constructionist genre of Making that intersects with the biological sciences, not much is known about its utility or impact in K-12 learning. We review a group of high school BioMaker projects submitted to an international design challenge. We use perspectives in cultural relevance to address the following research questions: (1) what do BioMaker projects reviewed reveal about Making in the context of life sciences and everyday life? and (2) in what ways is BioMaking distinct from traditional life science instantiations that emphasize active learning? We discuss BioMaking and its potential to respond to youth priorities and to broaden active learning to include lessons in design principles and social impacts. We conclude by highlighting the potential BioMaking has to broaden life science education priorities to include more critical stances about technology production and society.