1 January 2015 in Journal of Social Structure
We use balance theoretic ideas to study the dynamics of the international system of nations in a network of signed relations from 1946 through 1999. Using the Correlates of War data for this period, we apply pre-specified signed blockmodeling to characterize the fundamental structure of this network. Even though the system expanded greatly with many ties being created and/or destroyed, the basic structure remained the same but with new positions being added over time. The blockmodels generated temporal measures of imbalance, as did the counts of imbalanced triples. Regardless of using the line index of imbalance or the number of imbalanced 3-cycles, the results provided decisive evidence contradicting the balance theoretic hypothesis of signed networks moving towards balanced states. Structural balance theory remains very useful by pointing to the more important study of how and why signed networks move towards and away from balance at different points over time. Some major methodological problems for studying signed networks, regardless of whether they involve nations or human actors, were raised and addressed. Proposals for future research are suggested for modeling and understanding the dynamics of signed networks.
7 April 2015 in Scientometrics
This paper examines the collaboration structures and dynamics of the co-authorship network of all Slovenian researchers. Its goal is to identify the key factors driving collaboration and the main differences in collaboration behavior across scientific fields and disciplines. Two approaches to modelling network dynamics are combined in this paper: the small-world model and the mechanism of preferential attachment, also known as the process of cumulative advantage. Stochastic-actor-based modelling of co-authorship network dynamics uses data for the complete longitudinal co-authorship networks for the entire Slovenian scientific community from 1996 to 2010. We confirmed the presence of clustering in all fields and disciplines. Preferential attachment is far more complex than a single global mechanism. There were two clear distinctions regarding collaboration within scientific fields and disciplines. One was that some fields had an internal national saturation inhibiting further collaboration. The second concerned the differential impact of collaboration with scientists from abroad on domestic collaboration. In the natural, technical, medical, and biotechnical sciences, this promotes collaboration within the Slovenian scientific community while in the social sciences and humanities this inhibits internal collaboration.
1 March 2001 in The Journal of Mathematical Sociology
The fundamental empirical structural balance hypothesis claims that human signed networks tend towards balance over time. Balance theorists assume that there is a balance theoretic mechanism whose cumulative effect drives the evolution of signed social structures towards balance. In previous work, we used a line index of imbalance to measure the imbalance of a network through time. Consistent with balance theory, we found a steady movement towards balance in the well known “Newcomb data”. The balance mechanisms were, at best, implicit in that earlier analysis and our use of the line index of imbalance meant that we ignored triples. Here, we consider triples with the simple hypothesis that balanced triples exist at all times and, that through time, the balanced triples become more frequent while the unbalanced triples become less frequent. We examine pre‐transitive balance conditions defined in terms of the (i ?j, j ? k) ties and count the frequencies of the completion tie (i ? k) for each of the combinations of tie signs in the pre‐transitive condition. The basic structural balance theoretic hypotheses are supported ‐ but only partially. Worse, from a balance theoretic viewpoint, there are triples for which the fundamental structural balance hypothesis is contradicted. We construct three substantive arguments to account for the exceptions and end with a plea for the collection of much more appropriate data in order to disentangle multiple mechanisms.
26 March 2011 in Quality & Quantity
19 May 2014 in Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology