1 February 2017 in Applied Geography
24 October 2023 in Heliyon
SBSonoko Dorothea Bellingrath-Kimura
Sonoko Dorothea Bellingrath-Kimura
Transformation of agriculture to realise sustainable site-specific management requires comprehensive scientific support based on field experiments to capture the complex agroecological process, incite new policies and integrate them into farmers' decisions. However, current experimental approaches are limited in addressing the wide spectrum of sustainable agroecosystem and landscape characteristics and in supplying stakeholders with suitable solutions and measures. This review identifies major constraints in current field experimentation, such as a lack of consideration of multiple processes and scales and a limited ability to address interactions between them. It emphasizes the urgent need to establish a new category of landscape experimentation that empowers agricultural research on sustainable agricultural systems, aiming at elucidating interactions among various landscape structures and functions, encompassing both natural and anthropogenic features. It extensively discusses the key characteristics of landscape experiments and major opportunities to include them in the agricultural research agenda. In particular, simultaneously considering multiple factors, and thus processes at different scales and possible synergies or antagonisms among them would boost our understanding of heterogeneous agricultural landscapes. We also highlight that though various studies identified promising approaches with respect to experimental design and data analysis, further developments are still required to build a fully functional and integrated framework for landscape experimentation in agricultural settings.
10 November 2023 in Heliyon
Finding consensus in definitions of commonly-used terms and concepts is a key requirement to enable cooperations between interdisciplinary scientists and practitioners in inter- or transdisciplinary projects. In research on sustainable agriculture, the term ‘landscape’ is emphasised in particular, being used in studies that range from biogeochemical to socio-economic topics. However, it is normally used in a rather unspecific manner. Moreover, different disciplines assign deviating meanings to this term, which impedes interdisciplinary understanding and synthesis. To close this gap, a systematic literature review from relevant disciplines was conducted to identify a common understanding of the term “landscape”. Three general categories of landscape conceptualizations were identified. In a small subset of studies, “landscape” is defined by area size or by natural or anthropogenic borders. The majority of reviewed papers, though, define landscapes as sets of relationships between various elements. Selection of respective elements differed widely depending on research objects. Based on these findings, a new definition of landscape is proposed, which can be operationalized by interdisciplinary researchers to define a common study object and which allows for sufficient flexibility depending on specific research questions. It also avoids over-emphasis on specific spatio-temporal relations at the “landscape scale”, which may be context-dependent. Agricultural landscape research demands for study-specific definitions which should be meticulously provided in the future.
28 August 2018 in Regional Environmental Change
18 April 2026 in Landscape Ecology
Context: The recent decline in biodiversity, which is of particular concern in agriculturally managed landscapes, pushes researchers and practitioners to evaluate potential solutions, such as agricultural diversification. This requires the ability to provide robust conclusions about causal relationships in agroecosystems, which is hindered by limitations of conventional research methods. Findings from controlled plot experiments do not always translate to real-world conditions, while analysis of real-world data is often constrained by methodological difficulties. Objectives: The objectives of this study are (1) to apply a novel analytical framework in ecological and agricultural sciences in order to (2) provide robust evidence on ground beetle responses to different aspects of diversification in real-world agricultural landscapes. Methods: We applied the propensity-score analytical framework to ecological data collected in the landscape experiment patchCROP on species richness and activity density of carabid beetles. Results: The shift from large sole-cropped to small-scale and diversified fields and reduced agricultural management intensity led to a significant increase in species’ richness and activity density of carabids. Edge effects mainly manifested through increased species richness. Locations adjacent to flower strips did not show a significant increase in either response variable on average, but temporal variation of this effect was observed. Conclusion: Patch cropping combines the effects of small‑scale crop heterogeneity and high edge density. Combined with less intense agricultural management, it represents a beneficial strategy for supporting carabid beetle species richness and activity density. Further research is needed to explain the effect of flower strips, including sampling within the flower strips and accounting for predation.