10 March 2022 in Measurement Science and Technology
This work introduces a method to estimate the uncertainty of the pressure fields reconstructed from particle image velocimetry / particle tracking velocimetry (PIV/PTV) measurements by propagating the instantaneous velocity vector uncertainty through the pressure reconstruction. The uncertainty propagations through the calculation and integration of pressure gradients are modelled as linear transformations. The autocorrelation coefficient was modelled and incorporated in the uncertainty estimation to reproduce the effect of the autocorrelation of velocity errors on the reconstructed pressure’s accuracy. The method was first tested on synthetic velocity fields contaminated with varying levels of artificial noise correlated in space, time, or between components. The error analysis shows that the proposed method could predict the spatiotemporal variations of the pressure errors. The estimated pressure uncertainty also captures the effects of the velocity noise level, the autocorrelation, and the different pressure-gradient integration methods, with more than 80% accuracy in most test cases. The method was applied to an experimental vortex ring flow with planar PIV and a laminar pipe flow with volumetric PTV. The error analysis shows that the obtained pressure uncertainty possessed similar spatial and statistical distributions as the pressure errors. The results also indicate that the performance of the proposed uncertainty estimation method depends on the accuracy of the velocity uncertainty. The proposed uncertainty estimation method exhibits reliability in obtaining the local and instantaneous pressure uncertainty from the PIV/PTV measurements.
24 May 2022 in Measurement Science and Technology
We present a novel approach to estimate the uncertainty in ensemble particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements. The ensemble PIV technique is widely used when the cross-correlation signal-to-noise ratio is insufficient to perform a reliable instantaneous velocity measurement. Despite the utility of ensemble PIV, uncertainty quantification for this type of measurement has not been studied. Here, we propose a method for estimating the uncertainty directly from the probability density function of displacements found by deconvolving the ensemble cross-correlation from the ensemble autocorrelation. We then find the second moment of the probability density function and apply a scaling factor to report the uncertainty in the velocity measurement. We call this method the moment of probability of displacement (MPD). We assess MPD’s performance with synthetic and experimental images. We show that predicted uncertainties agree well with the expected root mean square (RMS) of the error in the velocity measurements over a wide range of image and flow conditions. MPD shows good sensitivity to various PIV error sources with around 86% accuracy in matching the RMS of the error in the baseline data sets. So, MPD establishes itself as a reliable uncertainty quantification algorithm for ensemble PIV. We compared the results of MPD against one of the existing instantaneous PIV uncertainty approaches, moment of correlation (MC). We adapted the MC approach for ensemble PIV, however, its primary limitations remain the assumption of the Gaussian probability density function of displacements and the Gaussian particles’ intensity profile. In addition, our analysis shows that ensemble MC consistently underestimates the uncertainty, while MPD outperforms that and removes the limiting Gaussian assumption for the particle and probability density function, thus overcoming the limitations of MC.
11 June 2021 in Measurement Science and Technology
Uncertainty quantification for particle image velocimetry (PIV) is critical for comparing experimentally measured flow fields with computational fluid dynamics results, and model design and validation. However, PIV features a complex measurement chain with coupled, non-linear error sources, and quantifying the uncertainty is challenging. Multiple assessments show that none of the current methods can reliably measure the actual uncertainty across a wide range of experiments, and estimates can vary. Because the current methods differ in assumptions regarding the measurement process and calculation procedures, it is not clear which method is best to use for an experiment where the error distribution is unknown. To address this issue, we propose a method to estimate an uncertainty method’s sensitivity and reliability, termed the Meta-Uncertainty. The novel approach is automated, local, and instantaneous, and based on perturbation of the recorded particle images. We developed an image perturbation scheme based on adding random unmatched particles to the interrogation window pair considering the signal-to-noise of the correlation plane. Each uncertainty scheme’s response to several trials of random particle addition is used to estimate a reliability metric, defined as the rate of change of the inter-quartile range of the uncertainties with increasing levels of particle addition. We also propose applying the meta-uncertainty as a weighting metric to combine uncertainty estimates from individual schemes, based on ideas from the consensus forecasting literature. We use planar and stereo PIV measurements across a range of canonical flows to assess the performance of the uncertainty schemes. Further, a novel method is introduced to assess an uncertainty scheme’s performance based on a quantile comparison of the error and uncertainty distributions, generalizing the current method of comparing the RMS of the two distributions. The results show that the combined uncertainty method outperforms the individual methods, and this work establishes the meta-uncertainty as a useful reliability assessment tool for PIV uncertainty quantification.
1 August 2021 in 14th International Symposium on Particle Image Velocimetry
Three-dimensional Particle Tracking Velocimetry (3D-PTV) is a non-invasive flow measurement technique that computes the velocity field by reconstructing 3D particle positions of individual tracer particles and by subsequently tracking those positions. The particle velocity measurement accuracy depends on the faithful reconstruction of 3D particle positions. The complex measurement chain in 3D-PTV involves several steps, from calibration to 3D position reconstruction and particle position tracking, each having its own source of error. Additionally, higher seeding density increases the uncertainty in particle reconstruction and tracking, which in turn, increases the noise in the estimated tracks. A noisy track decreases the measurement accuracy and amplifies any noise in the PTV-derived quantities of interest, which includes acceleration, pressure and vorticity. Thus, track filtering techniques are critical in a 3D-PTV measurement. Track fitting using polynomial functions, filtering methods adopted from signal processing and object tracking are among the well-established techniques used to achieve smooth position, velocity estimates from reconstructed particle trajectories. The Kalman filter is one such filtering technique that is widely used in various applications. The strength of the Kalman filter lies in its ability to perform noise reduction that is informed by existing physical models and the uncertainty estimates of recorded measurements. However, the measurement uncertainty input to the Kalman filter needs to be known at priori, which in many cases may not be available or could be difficult to estimate. In the literature on Kalman filters and their variants applied to 2D-PIV/PTV, the position uncertainty data fed to the filter is either user-defined or estimated based on global noise levels in the PTV measurements. But instantaneous position and velocity uncertainty quantification for individual particle positions/tracks has been challenging in the 3D PTV community. Recent work by Bhattacharya and Vlachos (2020) provides an estimate of the uncertainty in the reconstructed particle positions for a 3D PTV measurement. This position uncertainty estimate dynamically updates the filter gain for each track and enables the evaluation of the performance of the Kalman filter in 3D PTV track filtering.
1 August 2021 in 14th International Symposium on Particle Image Velocimetry
Pressure reconstruction from velocity measurements using particle image velocimetry (PIV) and particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) has drawn significant attention as it can provide instantaneous pressure fields without altering the flow. Previous studies have found that the accuracy of the calcualted pressure field depends on several factors including the accuarcy of the velocity measurement, the spatiotemporal resolutions, the method for calculating pressure-gradient, the algorithm for pressure-gradient integration, the pressure boundary condition, etc. Therefore, it is critical and challenging to quantify the uncertainty of the reconstructed pressure field. The recent development of the uncertainty quantification algorithms for PIV and PTV allows for the local and instantaneous uncertainty estimation of velocity measurement, which can be used to infer the pressure uncertainty. In this study, we introduce a framework that propagates the standard velocity uncertainty defined as the standard deviation of the velocity error distribution through the pressure reconstruction process to obtain the uncertainty of the pressure field. The uncertainty propagations through the calculation of the pressure-gradient and the pressure-gradient integration were modeled as linear transformations, which can reproduce the effects of the spatiotemporal resolutions, the numerical schemes, the integration algorithms, and the pressure boundary condition on the accuracy of the resulting pressure fields. The proposed uncertainty estimation approach also considers the effect of the spatiotemporal and componentwise correlation of the velocity errors in common PIV/PTV measurements on the pressure uncertainty.