Following a huge global effort, the first World Health Organization (WHO)-endorsed catalogue of 17,356 variants in the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex along with their classification as associated with resistance (interim), not associated with resistance (interim) or uncertain significance was made public In June 2021. This marks a critical step towards the application of next generation sequencing (NGS) data for clinical care. Unfortunately, the variant format used makes it difficult to look up variants when NGS data is generated by other bioinformatics pipelines. Furthermore, the large number of variants of uncertain significance in the catalogue hamper its useability in clinical practice. We successfully converted 98.3% of variants from the WHO catalogue format to the standardized HGVS format. We also created TBProfiler version 4.4.0 to automate the calling of all variants located in the tier 1 and 2 candidate resistance genes along with their classification when listed in the WHO catalogue. Using a representative sample of 339 clinical isolates from South Africa containing 691 variants in a tier 1 or 2 gene, TBProfiler classified 105 (15%) variants as conferring resistance, 72 (10%) as not conferring resistance and 514 (74%) as unclassified, with an average of 29 unclassified variants per isolate. Using a second cohort of 56 clinical isolates from a TB outbreak in Spain containing 21 variants in the tier 1 and 2 genes, TBProfiler classified 13 (61.9%) as unclassified, 7 (33.3%) as not conferring resistance, and a single variant (4.8%) classified as conferring resistance. Continued global efforts using standardized methods for genotyping, phenotyping and bioinformatic analyses will be essential to ensure that knowledge on genomic variants translates into improved patient care.
2 March 2022 in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making
Background: Personalized medicine tailors care based on the patient’s or pathogen’s genotypic and phenotypic characteristics. An automated Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) could help translate the genotypic and phenotypic characteristics into optimal treatment and thus facilitate implementation of individualized treatment by less experienced physicians. Methods: We developed a hybrid knowledge- and data-driven treatment recommender CDSS. Stakeholders and experts first define the knowledge base by identifying and quantifying drug and regimen features for the prototype model input. In an iterative manner, feedback from experts is harvested to generate model training datasets, machine learning methods are applied to identify complex relations and patterns in the data, and model performance is assessed by estimating the precision at one, mean reciprocal rank and mean average precision. Once the model performance no longer iteratively increases, a validation dataset is used to assess model overfitting. Results: We applied the novel methodology to develop a treatment recommender CDSS for individualized treatment of drug resistant tuberculosis as a proof of concept. Using input from stakeholders and three rounds of expert feedback on a dataset of 355 patients with 129 unique drug resistance profiles, the model had a 95% precision at 1 indicating that the highest ranked treatment regimen was considered appropriate by the experts in 95% of cases. Use of a validation data set however suggested substantial model overfitting, with a reduction in precision at 1 to 78%. Conclusion: Our novel and flexible hybrid knowledge- and data-driven treatment recommender CDSS is a first step towards the automation of individualized treatment for personalized medicine. Further research should assess its value in fields other than drug resistant tuberculosis, develop solid statistical approaches to assess model performance, and evaluate their accuracy in real-life clinical settings.
Background: Whole genome sequencing (WGS) holds great potential for the management and control of tuberculosis. Accurate analysis of samples with low mycobacterial burden, which are characterized by low (40%) levels of contamination, is challenging. We created the MAGMA (Maximum Accessible Genome for Mtb Analysis) bioinformatics pipeline for analysis of clinical Mtb samples. Methods and results: High accuracy variant calling is achieved by using a long seedlength during read mapping to filter out contaminants, variant quality score recalibration with machine learning to identify genuine genomic variants, and joint variant calling for low Mtb coverage genomes. MAGMA automatically generates a standardized and comprehensive output of drug resistance information and resistance classification based on the WHO catalogue of Mtb mutations. MAGMA automatically generates phylogenetic trees with drug resistance annotations and trees that visualize the presence of clusters. Drug resistance and phylogeny outputs from sequencing data of 79 primary liquid cultures were compared between the MAGMA and MTBseq pipelines. The MTBseq pipeline reported only a proportion of the variants in candidate drug resistance genes that were reported by MAGMA. Notable differences were in structural variants, variants in highly conserved rrs and rrl genes, and variants in candidate resistance genes for bedaquiline, clofazmine, and delamanid. Phylogeny results were similar between pipelines but only MAGMA visualized clusters. Conclusion: The MAGMA pipeline could facilitate the integration of WGS into clinical care as it generates clinically relevant data on drug resistance and phylogeny in an automated, standardized, and reproducible manner.
Improved understanding of the genomic variants that allow Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) to acquire drug resistance, or tolerance, and increase its virulence are important factors in controlling the current tuberculosis epidemic. Current approaches to Mtb sequencing, however, cannot reveal Mtb’s full genomic diversity due to the strict requirements of low contamination levels, high Mtb sequence coverage and elimination of complex regions. We have developed the XBS (compleX Bacterial Samples) bioinformatics pipeline, which implements joint calling and machine-learning-based variant filtering tools to specifically improve variant detection in the important Mtb samples that do not meet these criteria, such as those from unbiased sputum samples. Using novel simulated datasets, which permit exact accuracy verification, XBS was compared to the UVP and MTBseq pipelines. Accuracy statistics showed that all three pipelines performed equally well for sequence data that resemble those obtained from culture isolates of high depth of coverage and low-level contamination. In the complex genomic regions, however, XBS accurately identified 9.0 % more SNPs and 8.1 % more single nucleotide insertions and deletions than the WHO-endorsed unified analysis variant pipeline. XBS also had superior accuracy for sequence data that resemble those obtained directly from sputum samples, where depth of coverage is typically very low and contamination levels are high. XBS was the only pipeline not affected by low depth of coverage (5–10×), type of contamination and excessive contamination levels (>50 %). Simulation results were confirmed using whole genome sequencing (WGS) data from clinical samples, confirming the superior performance of XBS with a higher sensitivity (98.8%) when analysing culture isolates and identification of 13.9 % more variable sites in WGS data from sputum samples as compared to MTBseq, without evidence for false positive variants when rRNA regions were excluded. The XBS pipeline facilitates sequencing of less-than-perfect Mtb samples. These advances will benefit future clinical applications of Mtb sequencing, especially WGS directly from clinical specimens, thereby avoiding in vitro biases and making many more samples available for drug resistance and other genomic analyses. The additional genetic resolution and increased sample success rate will improve genome-wide association studies and sequence-based transmission studies.
19 July 2022 in Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Studies have shown that variants in bedaquiline-resistance genes can occur in isolates from bedaquiline-naive patients. We assessed the prevalence of variants in all bedaquiline-candidate-resistance genes in bedaquiline-naive patients, investigated the association between these variants and lineage, and the effect on phenotype.