Scholars have criticised reproductive self‐tracking software applications (apps) for reducing embodied experiences to objective quantifications and leading to user self‐alienation. Building on scholarly work that underscores the sensory and affective dimension of self‐tracking, this ethnographic study explores how users of contraceptive self‐tracking apps come to know their bodies during their everyday tracking practices. By relating tracking data to embodied experiences and relating their experiences back to the data, users produce knowledge of their own lived hormonal physiology. Users learn to articulate how their body feels and acts, foregrounding their body as an instrument of knowing alongside technical devices used. Users also articulate how their body is affected by everyday factors such as personal behaviours, diet, sleep and stress, thereby enacting what I call situated health. By foregrounding people’s sensory and affective engagements with their data and their bodies through self‐tracking, this study contributes to understanding how reproductive self‐tracking may be meaningful to users as well as encourages a move beyond the hierarchical opposition between ‘objective’ numerical data and embodied, lived experiences.
18 February 2025 in Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine
Patients’ online information-seeking and sharing has sparked worries about medical misinformation and declining trust in biomedical professionals. At the same time, scholars advocate for including patients as knowers in the clinical encounter. Yet we lack empirical insights into the differing ways care providers and patients substantiate health-related knowledge. This article thus examines (1) how both groups substantiate claims about contraceptive side-effects, (2) the ways their substantiation processes differ and (3) how we can navigate this epistemic tension in contraceptive care. I draw on data from nine interviews with Dutch contraceptive care providers (one nurse practitioner, one gynaecologist and seven general practitioners) and 17 contraceptive users, observations of 11 contraceptive consultations in the Netherlands and analysis of Dutch clinical guidelines. Results reveal that patients substantiate their claims through combining embodied modes of knowing with self-experimentation as well as validation through social media exchanges. Care providers switch between two complementary approaches: demarcating biomedical knowledge from non-scientific claims and clinical tinkering. I show that epistemic tensions between provider and patient may arise because the two groups have differing definitions of what a side-effect is and differing evaluations of information shared online. Based on these findings, I argue that care providers invalidating information shared online may contribute to patients’ growing distrust in biomedical authority while collaborative tinkering may provide a common ground for care providers and patients to co-create knowledge.
21 January 2025 in Science, Technology, & Human Values
Critical sociologists argue that reproductive self-tracking applications (apps) intensify existing norms regarding the female body. Yet, we have little empirical data on how self-care practiced with such apps relates to existing norms regarding the reproductive body in practice. Drawing on data from interviews with and solicited dairies from Dutch app users, I analyze contraceptive self-tracking practices as a form of self-care that renegotiates social norms. This study asks: In their everyday tracking, how do users of contraceptive apps grapple with social norms and expectations surrounding their body? Results reveal that self-care includes practices of attunement to and appreciation of the body that provide strategies to negotiate, navigate, and mitigate social norms and expectations. App users uphold ideals of femininity, the “natural” body, and “natural” cycles while also mobilizing them to thwart other norms and expectations, such as pressure to be productive and the expectation to take hormonal contraception. In what I call strategic nostalgia , users play social norms off each other to shape their lives in meaningful ways. This article aims to deepen understanding of everyday self-care practiced with reproductive self-tracking technologies through a praxiography of self-care that countervails analyses of reproductive self-tracking focused on discourse and app design.
24 January 2024 in European Journal of General Practice
A general practitioner (GP) standardly provides contraceptive counselling and care in the Netherlands. Recent years have seen the rise of mobile health technologies that aim to prevent pregnancy based on fertility awareness-based methods (FABMs). We lack high-quality evidence of these methods' effectiveness and clarity on how healthcare professionals include them in contraceptive counselling. To analyse how Dutch healthcare professionals include pregnancy-prevention mobile health technologies (mHealth contraception) in contraceptive counselling and to propose practice recommendations based on our findings. We used ethnographic methods, including semi-structured interviews with nine professionals who were recruited using purposive sampling, 10 observations of contraceptive counselling by four professionals, six observations of teaching sessions in medical training on contraception and reproductive health, one national clinical guideline, and seven Dutch patient decision aids. Data were collected between 2018 and 2021 and analysed inductively using praxiographic and thematic analysis. In contraceptive counselling and care, professionals tended to blend two approaches: 1) individual patient-tailored treatment and 2) risk minimisation. When interviewed about mHealth contraception, most professionals prioritised risk minimisation and forewent tailored treatment. Some did not consider mHealth contraception or FABMs as contraceptives or deemed them inferior methods. To minimise risk of unintended pregnancy, professionals hesitated to include mHealth contraception or other FABMs in contraceptive consultations. This may hamper adequate patient-centred counselling for patients with preference for mHealth contraception.Based on these results, we proposed recommendations that foster a patient-tailored approach to mHealth contraceptives.
For many people living with long COVID (PWLC), self‐tracking has emerged as a valuable practice to monitor their illness. An examination of self‐tracking practices can, therefore, shed light on the ways in which individuals navigate their care, make sense of their experiences and advocate for their needs. This study investigates how PWLC engage in self‐tracking practices and how they utilise and negotiate the data generated. Based on 33 semi‐structured interviews with PWLC in the Netherlands, Austria and Switzerland, we found that PWLC use self‐tracking to recognise patterns and identify limits, triggers and effective interventions. The insights drawn from this are used to make informed decisions about health management strategies. Yet, self‐tracking may also reify symptoms and negatively influence the subjective illness experience, exacerbating stress and anxiety. Although PWLC themselves negotiate and question their tracking data, they find a variety of responses from healthcare providers in clinical interactions. Using the concept of ‘trading zone’ (Kjærulff and Langstrup), we argue that although self‐tracking cannot replace treatment and good care, its integration into the healthcare experience as a valuable form of patient knowledge may improve the patient–provider relationship.
Nursing work is complex, as nurses strive to deliver care in a dynamic environment that is both strictly regulated and continually demands improvisation. As demands on this healthcare profession grow in tandem with worker shortages, the need for solutions, such as robotics, is an ever-growing desire. However, it remains difficult to develop robotic systems that integrate into nursing practice. This provocation challenges the prevailing methodologies that tend to adopt a technocentric focus on robotic systems for nursing, treating robots as isolated entities rather than situated and relational ones. We propose that performative approaches to developing robotic systems, i.e., approaches that understand experiences and interactions to emerge from people’s situated encounters with robotic artefacts, are critical to create robotic systems that can integrate into nursing practice. In this paper, we also elaborate on our planned study in which we intend to use Augmented Reality (AR) to stage situated encounters between nurses and a mimed assistive robot through speculative enactments. This work provokes a rethinking of how robotics can move beyond rigid control systems that provide predefined functions for nurses to robots as improvisation tools that nurses can use creatively. We argue that by inviting nurses in performative, real ward environments, we can find synergy between a robot’s physical constraints and people’s creative appropriation that is set within the complex reality of nursing work.