1 July 2013 in Solar Energy
21 October 2011 in Lighting Research & Technology
Discomfort glare is an underutilized parameter in contemporary architectural design due to uncertainties about the meaning of existing metrics, how they should be applied and what the benefits of such analysis are. Glare is position and view direction-dependent within a space, rendering it difficult to assess compared to conventional illuminance-based metrics. This paper compares simulation results for five glare metrics under 144 clear sky conditions in three spaces in order to investigate the ability of these metrics to predict the occurrence of discomfort glare and to hence support the design of comfortable spaces. The metrics analyzed areDaylight Glare Index, CIE Glare Index, Visual Comfort Probability, Unified Glare Rating and Daylight Glare Probability. It is found that Daylight Glare Probability yields the most plausible results. In an attempt to deal with multiple positions and view directions simultaneously, the concept of an ‘adaptive zone’ is introduced within which building occupants may freely adjust their position and view in order to minimise the effect of glare. The spatial and directional extents of the adaptive zone depend on furniture layout and the freedom of occupants’ tasks. It is found that applying the adaptive zone concept to a sidelit office with manually operated venetian blinds reduces the predicted hours of intolerable discomfort glare from 735 to 18 occupied hours per year and increases the annual mean daylight availability from 40% to 72%.
30 November 2015 in LEUKOS
A new visual comfort concept is introduced to describe the long-term visual impression of space occupants. This concept, in contrast to instantaneous assessment of visual comfort, aims to describe an overall rating of visual quality in a space. A paired study consisting of occupant surveys and detailed 6-minute time step visual comfort simulations was performed for the studio spaces of Gund Hall in Cambridge, Massachusetts, which is occupied by approximately 500 students. Occupants reported four primary ways of experiencing visual discomfort: discomfort glare, insufficient monitor contrast, direct visibility of the sun, and direct sunlight on the workplane. Survey results were located spatially and in terms of orientation within Gund Hall, and a simulation model was calibrated based on furniture layout, measured material reflectances, and local measured weather data. The results of the study illustrate that it is possible to use current simulation-based visual comfort predictions to predict occupants’ long-term visual comfort assessments in a complex daylit space. By classifying occupant responses into two broad groupings of comfortable and uncomfortable, the prediction methodology correctly identifies reported comfort or discomfort from 73.2% to 86.5% of cases depending on time of day; however, more research is required for broader application of the long-term visual comfort model to other buildings. Through a spatial and temporal presentation of the simulation data, this new methodology can be used as feedback during the process of designing daylit spaces, avoiding visual discomfort, and increasing satisfaction within the built environment.
1 January 2014 in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
Disability glare, or visual impairment due to extreme brightness or contrast, can be caused by intense reflections from new constructions onto existing transportation or building infrastructure located nearby. A case study analyzed a disability glare hazard at an airport created by the installation of a large array of photovoltaic panels between an air traffic control tower and the aircraft taxiway. The panels reflected blinding quantities of daylight into the control tower, produced temporary afterimages, and dangerously obscured taxiing aircraft. The existing FAA guidelines for installation of solar technologies are discussed relative to their shortcomings in identifying the glare hazard. High dynamic range photography was used to analyze the glaring situation at the airport. The authors proposed a maximum brightness threshold of 30,000 cd/m2 based on the physiology of human vision and the brightness of tasks necessary for air traffic controllers at the case study airport. Detailed reflectivity and three-dimensional models of the photovoltaic panels and the airport were created and validated against measured data. These models were used to perform an annual analysis of the glare hazard. This analysis is displayed temporally by graphs and spatially by images that indicate where the glaring reflections originate. Such information is useful in identifying potential for disability glare before new constructions are built. Finally, the authors used the new method to analyze designs for remediation of the glare hazard.