This study evaluated the effects of sedimentological and geochemical variables alongside seasonality on benthic macrofauna and ecological quality across macrotidal estuarine beaches subjected to varying degrees of anthropogenic influence in São Marcos Bay, Amazonian coast, via intertidal grid sampling in 2025. Carimã beach, in a conservation unit, presented a higher proportion of fine sand, lower organic matter, baseline trace element concentrations, and a typical biological zonation dominated by filter-feeding mollusks in the middle and lower grid levels. At Cajueiro beach, near a port complex, the continuous deposition of fine grains and organic matter favored trace element retention, resulting in manganese exceeding apparent biological effect thresholds and an isolated cadmium increase during the rainy season. This scenario caused an inversion of zonation, given that hypoxia in the muddy lower sediment excluded most organisms, restricting the community to the sandy upper level, dominated by tolerant annelids such as Heteromastus sp., Isolda pulchella Müller, 1858, Laeonereis culveri (Webster, 1879), and Sigambra grubei (Müller, 1858). Multivariate analyses indicated greater sample dispersion and benthic heterogeneity at Cajueiro. The Marine Biotic Index AMBI classified Carimã as disturbed due to natural saline dilution during the rainy season, whereas the multivariate index M-AMBI overestimated ecological quality at Cajueiro, as the diversity of tolerant taxa attenuated the sensitivity of multivariate metrics. Results demonstrate that port disturbances are superimposed on natural hydrodynamic processes, highlighting the need to integrate biological and geochemical parameters in estuarine coastal monitoring.