31 August 2023 in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
Purpose: The development of circular construction supply chains (CCSCs) is impeded by various barriers, but the current literature overlooks the interrelationships among these barriers and the varying nature of associated countermeasures with the growth of circular economy (CE). This paper aims to develop new perspectives about the transition to CCSCs through the lens of supply-push (SP)/demand-pull (DP) strategies and related underpinning theories.Design/methodology/approach: A systematic literature review including 136 journal articles was undertaken to identify barriers to CCSCs and associated countermeasures that are analysed for their relevance to SP/DP. The interplay between SP/DP approaches was discussed using the “technology acceptance” and “innovation chain” models.Findings: (1) Thirty-five barriers were identified and organised into nine main barrier factors; (2) the predominant factors are knowledge and awareness, policy and regulations, technological capabilities, and incentives; (3) CCSCs transition is SP-configured primarily driven by actors above the project network; (4) “push” measures are devised to gradually create a “pull” environment and can be revoked when demand for circularity is created, suggesting a new “push-to-pull” perspective of CCSCs; and (5) a complex adaptative system is witnessed in relationships between barriers and countermeasures, and interactions among actors at all levels.Practical implications: The findings offer practitioners countermeasures to barriers encountered in CE initiatives. It also informs policymakers of adjusting policies to accommodate the SP-DP movement in steering the circular transition.Originality/value: This study uses theoretical models to interpret the dynamics in CCSCs transition and proposes a new definition of CCSCs highlighting their complex and dual transitional/transformational nature.
18 June 2025 in Waste Management
Circular economy (CE) provokes a rethink of construction supply chains by integrating reverse logistics (RL) to promote reuse and recycling of construction materials. However, the situation in construction is still lagging behind other sectors due to various barriers. Policy support plays an indispensable role in driving top-down momentum towards CE. While previous studies have explored the barriers to RL in construction, the interdependencies of these barriers and their relevance to CE policies have been largely overlooked. This study conducted an expert workshop to develop an overarching policy framework for RL development towards circular construction. A system dynamics (SD) model was developed using the Fuzzy-DEMATEL method to grasp the interrelationships between RL barriers and explore the potential of policy interventions for their mitigation. The proposed model comprised twenty-five barriers organised into six barrier factors. Results revealed that the lack of "knowledge and awareness", and "policy and regulation" were the root causes of other barriers. Establishing CE standards and guidelines is pivotal to shaping CE policies and easing the barriers. Current CE initiatives were driven by a soft voluntary policy approach, while the significance of hard mandatory regulations was undermined, which has slowed down the transition. A policy framework adopting a staggered approach was proposed for a strategic regulation control, starting with supportive polices and gradually advancing to stringent regulations over time. This will support policymakers in devising high-leverage policies. Future research will target a specific material supply chain to develop a framework of bespoke policy interventions to optimise its RL.
30 September 2025 in Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
Purpose: The circular economy (CE) paradigm has helped the building sector reduce its environmental impacts. However, existing circularity assessment (CA) frameworks have not guided practitioners in making circular decisions at the project frontend. This paper develops and validates a CA framework to inform circular decision-making (DM) at an early stage in building projects. Design/methodology/approach: The proposed CA framework, comprising 12 circularity indicators (CIs), was calibrated using the analytic hierarchy process. A state-of-the-art case study, involving a cutting-edge engineering building at the forefront of the sustainability design stage, was undertaken to validate the proposed model and identify potential challenges through the lens of the theory of planned behaviour (TPB). Findings: (1) Current building sustainability assessments lack clear conceptual contours between different pathways to sustainability due to a focus on carbon/energy instead of materials flows; (2) the fragmentation of project roles resulted in a lack of collaborative effort in CA, with designers primarily driven by clients’ requirements and often emphasising traditional sustainability metrics over circularity benefits; and (3) the transition to CE in the built environment has been partial and completing the transition involves a behaviour change case including all stakeholders. Research limitations/implications: This study contributes to the current body of knowledge by revealing behavioural challenges related to CA within the field of circular building design. It supports building designers to embed CA in building projects’ front-end DM. It also refocuses policymakers’ attention to embodied carbon, circular public procurement and economic incentives as levers for driving CA implementation. Originality/value: The validation of a novel set of CIs using a cutting-edge building project case study offers unique insights, underpinned by TPB, into behavioural challenges, relevant to incorporating circularity into frontend DM processes.
1 April 2023 in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Management, Procurement and Law
Sustainable construction has gained increasing popularity within the building sector with many sustainability rating systems (SRSs) available worldwide. However, most research has been focused on the environmental benefits of pursuing SRSs, with little attention paid to the health and safety (H&S) impact on construction workers. This study thus aims to investigate the impact of adopting SRSs on the H&S of construction workers in building projects. A systematic literature review was conducted, including 39 articles, to investigate the possible association between sustainability and H&S hazards. It resulted in 30 events and eight types of associated hazards, which are mostly related to the adoption of the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (Leed) and Hong Kong Building Environmental Assessment Method SRSs. The adoption of SRSs is likely to increase the exposure of workers to known H&S hazards with no new hazards introduced. In particular, ‘falling from height’ and ‘manual handling injuries’ caused by solar installation and retrieving recyclable waste, respectively, are the most representative sustainability-related hazards. While the evidence detected is mainly related to Leed, further research is needed to investigate whether findings are valid for other SRSs, such as the Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method in the UK or Green Star in Australia, to address H&S concerns associated with sustainable building projects.
9 November 2026 in Journal of Management in Engineering
Circular economy (CE) in the building sector has been largely constrained to recycling, despite reuse offering significantly greater resource benefits. Building materials differ in their reuse potential, with steel and plasterboard representing opposite ends of the reusability spectrum. However, the criteria for assessing reusability are yet to be fully investigated. This study aims to develop a reusability assessment framework for building materials. A series of semistructured interviews and a survey involving 30 supply-chain stakeholders were conducted to identify reusability assessment criteria through a comparative analysis of barriers across the two material cases. The proposed framework comprises 24 criteria classed under two dimensions: material attributes and building lifecycle stages. The plasterboard case identified economic value and ease of deconstruction as gating criteria, positioning plasterboard at the low end of the reusability spectrum that requires a “start-up” strategy. Potential pathways were proposed to unlock plasterboard reuse, including adaptive reuse, modular construction, standardization, reversible fixings, servitization, and community-based business models. At the high end, barriers to the “scale-up” of steel reuse highlighted additional criteria, such as pricing, stockholding, and market demand. The study proposes a practical reuse guidance aligned with the Royal Institute of British Architects stages and informs policymakers by distinguishing “scale-up” and “start-up” strategies for materials with differing reuse potential, while recognizing material substitution where reuse is not feasible. It supports a phased policy approach in which interventions are aligned with market maturity and combine both “carrots” (incentives) and “sticks” (mandates). Future research should validate the framework across additional materials and develop a weighting system to improve its applicability.