Adam Stuart Bass

Adam Stuart Bass

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Adam Stuart Bass

University of Calgary

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
13 October 2021 in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
HAHaris Masood Ansari
Haris Masood Ansari
ABAdam Stuart Bass
Adam Stuart Bass
NANabeel Ahmad
Nabeel Ahmad
VBViola I. Birss
Viola I. Birss
In situ exsolved Fe–Ni nanoparticles anchored on a (La0.3Ca0.7)0.95Fe0.7Cr0.25Ni0.05O3−δ parent perovskite surface significantly enhance the CO oxidation kinetics, thus reaching excellent activity of the CO2 reduction reaction.

22 December 2023 in ECS Meeting Abstracts
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SBSara Bouzidi
Sara Bouzidi
HAHaris Masood Ansari
Haris Masood Ansari
ABAdam Stuart Bass
Adam Stuart Bass
VBViola Ingrid Birss
Viola Ingrid Birss
Solid Oxide Fuel Cells (SOFCs) and Solid Oxide Electrolysis Cells (SOECs) are highly useful devices, capable of generating and storing large amounts of energy, respectively.1 They can do this by catalyzing CO oxidation at a SOFC anode and CO2 reduction (CO2RR) at a SOEC cathode, while the other electrode catalyzes oxygen reduction or evolution. The conduction of oxide ions through the electrolyte completes the circuit, making Solid Oxide Cells (SOCs) an excellent choice for clean energy production and use since there are no undesired byproducts.1 While traditional SOC electrodes are composed of oxide-conducting ceramics mixed with electronically conducting metals,1 a newer category of catalysts are Mixed Ionic Electronic Conductors (MIECs), with one example being the perovskite La0.3M0.7Fe0.7Cr0.3O3-δ (M = Sr, Ca) (LMFCr), investigated heavily by our group.2,3,4 As an MIEC, the full surface of LMFCr is electrochemically active, giving excellent activity at both the cathode and anode, including for CO2RR and CO oxidation.2,3 However, efforts are being made to further improve the CO2RR-CO oxidation kinetics and durability, with the Ca analogue having a better chemical match with standard electrolytes.4 One approach used recently to improve MIEC oxide performance is B-site doping with transition metals (TMs) while also creating an A-site deficiency, resulting in nanoparticle (NP) formation (exsolution) when the perovskite is subjected to reducing conditions.2 For instance, Fe-Ni NPs of a ~20 nm average size can be exsolved from (La0.3Ca0.7)0.95Fe0.7Cr0.25Ni0.05O3-δ(LCFCrNi), even at 600 °C in 70CO2:30CO (pO2 ~10-18 atm). Furthermore, NP features can easily be tailored by changing the reducing conditions or dopant used.2 In general, higher temperatures and lower pO2 lead to larger NPs over time, and more easily reducible metals tend to exsolve first under less harshly reducing conditions.2 Recent studies have suggested that NP formation enhances electrocatalytic activity by creating additional sites of reactivity, suggesting that strong NP-substrate interactions are important to catalysis.5 However, there is no clear understanding of the role played by exsolved NPs in catalyzing SOC reactions. To gain further insights, detailed electrochemical studies of LCFCrNi electrodes were done on 1-inch diameter cells constructed using Samarium-Doped Ceria buffered Scandia-Stabilized Zirconia electrolyte substrates. LCFCrNi was made into an ink and tape-cast on 0.5 cm2 on one side (working electrode, WE) and 1 cm2 on the other (counter electrode, CE) on each substrate. The cells were sintered at 1100 °C for 2 h, coated with Au ink, and sintered at 850 °C for 1 h. Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) was performed at 600 °C with 70CO2:30CO at the WE and air at the CE, followed by exsolution in 5H2:95N2 at a higher temperature, and then EIS was repeated multiple times under the same conditions at 600 °C. Cells were imaged via Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) after ramping down to room temperature in N2 to determine the size and distribution of the NPs for each set of exsolution conditions. Under all conditions employed, the polarization resistance (Rp) was found to be stable before exsolution occurred, but started decreasing once the NPs formed, especially via a shrinking of the low frequency resistance. The low frequency resistance has been associated with CO oxidation,2 so the fact that it improves with exsolution is an indication that the increased electrode area serves to improve CO oxidation more than CO2RR. When exsolution was carried out at 800 °C for 25 h, Rp decreased more rapidly than after exsolution at 800 °C for 14 h. Exsolution at 800 °C for 25 h also showed a more rapid decrease in Rp compared to 700 °C exsolution for 25 h. These results argue that the initial formation of larger NPs (formed after longer time or at a higher temperature) results in a faster increase in the active surface area of the electrode at the lower 600 °C temperature. Further experiments are being carried out to better understand whether it is the growth of NPs or new NP formation after higher temperature exsolution that is the reason behind this observation. The results of operando synchrotron studies in CO2/CO environments before and after exsolving, as well as the use of different transition metal dopants, are also being investigated for this purpose. References [1] Mogensen, Current Opinion in Electrochemistry, 2020, 21, 265-273. [2] Ansari et al., Journal of Materials Chemistry A,2022, 10, 2280–2294. [3] Addo et al., Fuel Cells, 2015, 15, 689-696. [4] Molero-Sánchez et al., International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2015, 40, 1902-1910. [5] Xiong, X. et al., Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 2022, 125, 51-58.

22 December 2023 in ECS Meeting Abstracts
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ABAdam Stuart Bass
Adam Stuart Bass
ASAnand Chandra Singh
Anand Chandra Singh
SPScott Paulson
Scott Paulson
VBViola Ingrid Birss
Viola Ingrid Birss
As the world moves to decarbonize the fossil fuel sector, transition technologies are needed that bridge the gap between natural gas power plants and more sustainable low-carbon energy sources. These newer technologies often still rely on fossil fuels but have improved energy conversion efficiencies and lower net carbon dioxide (CO2) outputs over conventional fossil fuel based electric power generation systems. In this work, we are exploring one such technology, namely the use of a syngas-fed solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) to generate heat, electricity, steam, and captured CO2. Core to this technology is the mixed ion electron conductor deployed at the anode and cathode that catalyzes all of the relevant reactions, namely electrochemical oxidation of hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO) at the anode, producing steam and CO2, and reduction of oxygen at the cathode. Carbon formation (coking) is normally a significant problem affecting SOFCs operating on carbon-based fuels, as it leads to a rapid decline in electrochemical performance by blocking catalytically active sites and pores with various carbon species, e.g., amorphous, graphitic, or nanotubular carbon.1 The formation of carbon species from syngas is known to occur through various mechanisms, with the Boudouard reaction (∆H= -172 kJ/mol) and the reduction of CO (∆H= -131 kJ/mol) being the most prominent.2 As such, temperature is a key parameter to optimize as it determines the propensity for carbon formation at equilibrium. In addition, the kinetics of carbon formation can be significantly reduced by introducing oxygen to the fuel gas stream in the form of O2, CO2, or H2O.3 The catalyst materials investigated here are mixed conducting perovskite oxides (La0.3Ca0.7Fe0.7Cr0.3O3- δ, LCFCr) that have been optimized and modified recently by our group, both in the as-prepared undoped form and after B-site doping with variable quantities of transition metals (M), e.g., Ni,4 forming nanoparticle (NP)-decorated ABO3-Mx surfaces. Our catalyst is highly active for H2 and CO oxidation, CO2 reduction, and O2 reduction, where it was demonstrated that the un-doped parent material can deliver a stable power density of 0.2 W/cm2 for several hundred hours with negligible performance degradation in 3% humidified H2.5 In more recent work, excellent resilience to carbon deposition for exsolved Fe-Ni@LCFCr up to 70:30 CO:CO2 was demonstrated.4 Herein, we show that minimal coke forms during exposure of these materials to dry syngas at 600oC, even under open circuit conditions. The catalysts were prepared using combustion synthesis and were characterized by XRD, SEM EDX, and TPO-MS in order to confirm morphology, crystal structure, and composition as a function of temperature and gas environment.4 Symmetrical electrolyte-supported SOFCs were constructed using our catalyst as both the anode and cathode. Catalyst layers of 1 cm2 were screen printed to a thickness of 25 µm on both sides of commercially available 130 µm thick samaria-doped ceria (SDC)-buffered scandia-stabilized zirconia (ScSZ) electrolyte, followed by sintering at 1100°C for 2 h,4 with porous metal current collectors used. The cells were mounted and tested in a Fiaxel SOFC test station with gas flow controlled by mass flow controllers. Preliminary electrochemistry experiments were conducted in 5:95 H2:N2, or 1:1 H2:CO (syngas) balanced by CO2 in a 1:2 ratio of fuel to oxidant into the anode chamber, and air into the cathode chamber at 600 oC, with performance evaluation carried out using CV, EIS and chronopotentiometry. The power density was found to be ca. 2x higher in dry H2 vs. in syngas, as expected, considering that H2 is a more active fuel vs. CO. Additionally, EIS exhibited ca. 2x higher resistance in the low frequency arc in syngas, which can be attributed to sluggish CO oxidation kinetics.4 Chronopotentiometry was performed for 20 h at 10 mA cm-2, showing a degradation rate of only 0.08 mV h-1, suspected to be primarily due to current collector delamination. Coking studies were also conducted on button cells at 600 oC in 1:1 H2:CO for 25 h at open circuit, comparing to a NiO standard that was painted on the electrolyte just next to the LCFCr-Ni working electrode. Imaging by SEM showed negligible carbon formation on the perovskite surface, supported by EDX analysis, compared to the extensive degree of coking observed at the standard. Further quantification was conducted by TPO-MS, also confirming minimal carbon formation. References Bengaard et al., Journal of Catalysis, 2002, 209, 365–384. Farshchi Tabrizi et al., Energy Conversion and Management, 2015, 103, 1065–1077. Sasaki et al., Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 2003, 150. Ansari et al., Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2022, 10, 2280–2294. Addo et al., ECS Transactions, 2015, 66, 219–228.

24 November 2025 in ECS Meeting Abstracts
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ABAdam Stuart Bass
Adam Stuart Bass
ASAnand Singh
Anand Singh
SPScott Paulson
Scott Paulson
VBViola Ingrid Birss
Viola Ingrid Birss
Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) are efficient combined heat and power devices that can flexibly operate on a variety of fuels, such as H 2 , CO, or hydrocarbons. Shifting to these alternative fuels as a primary energy source can contribute significantly to the decarbonization of the energy sector, as electrochemical oxidation of these fuels produces H 2 O and capture-ready CO 2 . Additionally, power production from hydrocarbons, for example, could serve as an effective approach to allow for continued development of the oil and gas sector, while still achieving significantly reduced emissions during energy production. The long-term stability of SOFCs is still a major challenge that is hindering widespread commercialization. The prominent reason for this is the high operating temperatures, which greatly accelerate degradation phenomena. Particle sintering, phase segregation, cation migration, and microstructural changes are some of the major challenges to overcome when it comes to electrode design. 1,2,3 Traditional anode materials currently employed in SOFC systems are composite cermets, such as Ni- yttria-stabilized zirconia or Ni- gadolinium-doped ceria. 4,5 These materials are well known for suffering deactivation due to the aforementioned causes of degradation, including morphology change, carbon deposition in hydrocarbon fuels and sulfur poisoning. 6 Therefore, perovskite systems, such as La-based La x A 1-x BO 3-δ (A = Sr, Zr, Y; B = Cr, Fe, Ni, Co, Mn), have emerged as next generation anode materials due to their high redox stability at intermediate and high operating temperatures (500-800 o C). 7,8,9,10 Our group has been developing and modifying a perovskite oxide (ABO 3 ) catalyst with the specific formula of La 0.3 Ca 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3-x M x O 3-δ (M = Ni, Co, Cu). Investigations of this material and its analogue, La 0.3 Sr 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3 O 3-δ , have established a stability window in mixtures of CO 2 -CO, showing that the perovskite phase remains intact under a pO 2 window of 0.21-10 -21 atm. 11 Consistent with this, these catalysts have displayed high activity towards many reactions, such as H 2 oxidation, steam reduction, oxygen reduction, oxygen evolution, CO oxidation, and CO 2 reduction. 11,12,13,14 Further enhancement in conversion kinetics has been achieved by decorating the catalyst surface with transition metal nanoparticles (NPs) though exsolution. For example, we have demonstrated that exsolved Ni NPs can enhance the kinetics of CO 2 reduction at 800 o C by ~15% and CO oxidation by ~75%. In addition, these NPs display no carbon formation in 90:10 CO:CO 2 for 25 hours at 800 o C. 15 Here, we have expanded on prior work with La 0.3 Ca 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3-x Ni x O 3-δ (LCFCrNi) and its parent materials by studying the long-term performance and durability in a simulated 100% fully reformed gas mixture of 1:2 CH 4 :H 2 O, which would generate 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 upon complete steam methane reforming. Material phase, morphology, and structure changes as a function of long-term constant current experiments are also being explored. LCFCr and its doped analogues were prepared by combustion synthesis and characterized by SEM/EDX, TEM, and XRD, to confirm morphology, crystal structure, and composition as a function of temperature and gas environment. 15 Symmetrical electrolyte-supported SOFCs were constructed using our catalyst, with LCFCrNi at the anode (0.5 cm 2 ) and LCFCr at the cathode (1 cm 2 ), with the catalyst layers screen-printed on both sides of a samaria-doped ceria (SDC)-buffered scandia-stabilized zirconia (ScSZ) electrolyte (ca. 150 μm). This was followed by sintering at 1100 °C for 2 h in air, with porous Au current collectors used. Electrochemical evaluation was conducted at 800 o C under 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 with the gas flow rates and composition controlled by mass flow controllers. Under both open circuit and polarized conditions, durability was measured in-situ for 100-250 h, with electrochemical impedance spectroscopy carried out every 20 h to track changes in resistance and capacitance. Additionally, gas analysis was carried out by on-line mass spectrometry to verify outlet gas composition and fuel utilization. Figure 1a shows the current-voltage data obtained from a SOFC with a LCFCrNi anode in 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 and 4:1 H 2 :N 2 at 800 °C. Under 4:1 H 2 :N 2 , a maximum power density of 0.43 W/cm 2 was achieved at 0.92 A/cm 2 (0.20 V overpotential vs. LCFCr reference in air). The reformed gas mixture (4:1 H 2 :CO 2 ) has a 22% lower performance, achieving a maximum power output of 0.35 W/cm 2 at the same overpotential. This is explained by the reverse water-gas shift reaction producing CO, which could have more sluggish oxidation kinetics compared to H 2 . 16 Reverse water-gas shift reaction also consumes H2 to produce H2O, thereby decreasing the H2 concentration at the anode. The OCV in 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 is ca 1.0 V and significantly lower than the OCV value of 1.15 V in 4:1 H 2 :N 2 at 800 °C. The difference in OCV values suggests that pO2 in 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 is significantly higher than in 4:1 H 2 :N 2 , thereby reducing the driving force. Chronopotentiometry experiments were carried out at 0.35 A/cm 2 at an anode overpotential of 0.16 V (vs. a LCFCr reference electrode placed on the cathode side of the button cell) to analyze the durability of the SOFC in 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 . Biased EIS data were acquired every 20 hours to track changes in the resistors and capacitors, revealing that Rs increased from 0.37 to 0.41 Ω cm 2 (14% increase), while Rp increased from 0.52 to 0.67 Ω cm 2 (29% increase), occurring predominantly in the low-frequency arc, while the capacitance of the low frequency arc was not observed to change. Initial investigations into the causes of the observed degradation have highlighted the porous Au current collectors as the primary source of degradation due to the observed increase in Rs. Post-mortem analysis was performed on both the anode and cathode by SEM to investigate if any structural and morphological changes occurred after 100 h. Figure 1b shows the full cross-section of one button cell, showing the current collector, electrode, buffer and electrolyte layers and their corresponding thicknesses and microstructure. Here, we utilized a ca. 20 µm thick anode and 30 µm thick cathode, both with particle sizes of ca. 1-2 µm and a porosity estimated to be 50%. Higher magnification images of the anode and cathode are shown in Figures 2a-d. The cathode, imaged near the SDC buffer layer (Figure 2a-b), is observed to maintain high quality LCFCr/Au and LCFCr/SDC interfaces, with smooth surfaces and no structural or morphological changes occurring after 100 h of oxygen reduction. The anode surface (Figure 2c-d) also shows high quality LCFCrNi/Au and LCFCrNi/SDC interfaces, with no signs of delamination. After pre-reduction at 800 o C for 2 h under 5% H 2 /95% N 2 , the anode surface undergoes significant re-crystallization, appearing as surface roughening. Additionally, NPs are observed to cover the surface, appearing predominantly hemispherical, ca. 60 nm in size, and distributed homogeneously across grains without a preference for exsolution at grain boundaries. Notably, NP coverage is observed throughout the entire thickness of the anode, although some regions showed much higher population densities. The surface roughening appears identical as compared to a reference LCFCrNi sample that was pre-reduced for 2 h under 5% H 2 /95% N 2 at 800 o C but not exposed to 4:1 H 2 :CO 2. Hence, re-crystallization likely only occurs under highly reducing conditions, as this was not observed for the cathode. Further analysis of the NPs by TEM, on a LCFCrNi powder sample pre-reduced under the same conditions described above for the anode (Figure 2g), revealed that, after 2 hours of reduction, the NPs formed are highly amorphous and are composed of 98% Ni - 2% Fe. Comparison of the average NP population density, diameter, and crystallinity between the anode and the pre-reduced reference LCFCrNi (Figures 2c-d and 2e-f) suggests that, for mixed conductors such as LCFCrNi, which readily undergo exsolution, anodic polarization effectively prevents NP growth, as metal reduction can not occur under these conditions. Another notable observation is the enrichment of Fe and Ni NPs seen at the Au current collector/LCFCrNi interface, which is still not fully understood. This may not be a negative feature, as this may enhance the quality of interfacial bonding. Upon cooling to room temperature under flowing 4:1 H 2 :CO 2 , NiO and Fe 2 O 3 are detected on the surface of the Au current collector surface by EDX. Other work includes determining the effect of different pre-reduction (exsolution) and operating conditions, including gas composition, temperature, and operating current, on exsolved metal NP size and distribution, as well as electrochemical performance and durability. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge Mykhailo Pidburtnyi for helpful discussions regarding the interpretation of results. Additionally, we recognize Occam’s Technologies, Precision Drilling, and the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) for financial support of this work. References Zarabi Golkhatmi, S.; Asghar, M. I.; Lund, P. D. A Review on Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Durability: Latest Progress, Mechanisms, and Study Tools. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2022 , 161, 112339. DOI:10.1016/j.rser.2022.112339. Mehran, M. T.; Khan, M. Z.; Song, R.-H.; Lim, T.-H.; Naqvi, M.; Raza, R.; Zhu, B.; Hanif, M. B. A Comprehensive Review on Durability Improvement of Solid Oxide Fuel Cells for Commercial Stationary Power Generation Systems. Applied Energy 2023 , 352, 121864. DOI:10.1016/j.apenergy.2023.121864. Mahato, N.; Banerjee, A.; Gupta, A.; Omar, S.; Balani, K. Progress in Material Selection for Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Technology: A Review. Progress in Materials Science 2015 , 72, 141–337. DOI:10.1016/j.pmatsci.2015.01.001. Shao, X.; Budiman, R. A.; Sato, T.; Yamaguchi, M.; Kawada, T.; Yashiro, K. Review of Factors Affecting the Performance Degradation of Ni-Ysz Fuel Electrodes in Solid Oxide Electrolyzer Cells. Journal of Power Sources 2024 , 609, 234651. DOI:10.1016/j.jpowsour.2024.234651. Ahmed, N.; Devi, S.; Dar, M. A.; Ibrahim, S. K.; Sharma, A.; Sharma, N.; Paul, S.; Ahamed, S. R. Anode Material for Solid Oxide Fuel Cell: A Review. Indian Journal of Physics 2023 , 98 (3), 877–888. DOI:10.1007/s12648-023-02860-3. Christensen, K. O.; Chen, D.; Lødeng, R.; Holmen, A. Effect of Supports and Ni Crystal Size on Carbon Formation and Sintering during Steam Methane Reforming. Applied Catalysis A: General 2006 , 314 (1), 9–22. DOI:10.1016/j.apcata.2006.07.028. Jiang, S. P. Development of Lanthanum Strontium Cobalt Ferrite Perovskite Electrodes of Solid Oxide Fuel Cells – a Review. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 2019 , 44 (14), 7448–7493. DOI:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2019.01.212. Hussain, S.; Yangping, L. Review of Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Materials: Cathode, Anode, and Electrolyte. Energy Transitions 2020 , 4 (2), 113–126. DOI:10.1007/s41825-020-00029-8. Zhang, S.; Wan, Y.; Xu, Z.; Xue, S.; Zhang, L.; Zhang, B.; Xia, C. Bismuth Doped La 75 Sr 0.25 Cr 0.5 Mn 0.5 O 3−δ Perovskite as a Novel Redox-Stable Efficient Anode for Solid Oxide Fuel Cells. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2020 , 8 (23), 11553–11563. DOI:10.1039/d0ta03328f. de Larramendi, I. R.; Ortiz-Vitoriano, N.; Dzul-Bautista, I. B.; Rojo, T. Designing Perovskite Oxides for Solid Oxide Fuel Cells. Perovskite Materials - Synthesis, Characterisation, Properties, and Applications 2016 . DOI:10.5772/61304. Ansari, H. M.; Addo, P. K.; Mulmi, S.; Yuan, H.; Botton, G. A.; Thangadurai, V.; Birss, V. I. Deciphering the Interaction of Single-Phase La 3 Sr 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3 O 3-δ with CO2/CO Environments for Application in Reversible Solid Oxide Cells. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 2022 , 14 (11), 13388–13399. DOI:10.1021/acsami.2c00857. Addo, P. K.; Molero-Sanchez, B.; Buyukaksoy, A.; Paulson, S.; Birss, V. Sulfur Tolerance of La 3 M 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3 O 3-δ (M= Sr, Ca) Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Anodes. ECS Transactions 2015 , 66 (2), 219–228. DOI:10.1149/06602.0219ecst. Molero-Sánchez, B.; Prado-Gonjal, J.; Ávila-Brande, D.; Chen, M.; Morán, E.; Birss, V. High Performance La 3 Ca 0.7 Cr 0.3 Fe 0.7 O 3−δ Air Electrode for Reversible Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Applications. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 2015 , 40 (4), 1902–1910. DOI:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2014.11.127. Molero-Sánchez, B.; Addo, P.; Buyukaksoy, A.; Birss, V. Performance Enhancement of La 3 Ca 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3 O 3-δ Air Electrodes by Infiltration Methods. Journal of The Electrochemical Society 2017 , 164 (10). DOI:10.1149/2.0151710jes. Ansari, H. M.; Bass, A. S.; Ahmad, N.; Birss, V. I. Unraveling the Evolution of Exsolved Fe–Ni Alloy Nanoparticles in Ni-Doped La 3 Ca 0.7 Fe 0.7 Cr 0.3 O 3− δ and Their Role in Enhancing CO 2 –CO Electrocatalysis. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2022 , 10 (5), 2280–2294. DOI: 10.1039/D1TA07552G Zhang, W.; Hu, Y. H. Material Design and Performance of Carbon Monoxide‐fueled Solid Oxide Fuel Cells: A Review. Energy Science & Engineering 2023 , 11 (9), 3276–3288. DOI:10.1002/ese3.1502. Figure 1 Figure 2