18 September 2026 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Wood remains the material of choice for musical instrument soundboards, but its inherent physical and mechanical variability limits the reproducibility of vibroacoustic behaviour across nominally identical instruments. This study quantifies the vibroacoustic reproducibility achieved by additive manufacturing in soprano ukulele construction, compared against two traditional tonewoods (Engelmann spruce and Chilean laurel), across three successive stages of assembly: free soundboards, soundboards coupled to identical 3D-printed bodies (full soundboxes), and complete assembled instruments. In the first two stages the soundboard is the only variable; at the complete-instrument stage the comparison extends to three independently fabricated ukuleles, so that the additional variability introduced by assembly, stringing and setup is also included. Inter-specimen similarity was quantified using metrics matched to the nature of each measured signal: the Pearson correlation coefficient for free-plate spectra, FRAC-based metrics for full soundbox admittance, and the Modal Assurance Criterion for mode shapes of complete instruments. Free PLA+ plates showed substantially higher intra-group correlation ($\bar{r}=0.87\pm0.02$) than Engelmann spruce ($0.58\pm0.11$) and Chilean laurel ($0.39\pm0.07$), a pattern that persisted against laurel but not against spruce at the full soundbox stage, where PLA+ and spruce became statistically indistinguishable, behaviour mainly attributed to the manufacturing process, specifically to the coupling between the body and the soundboard. Inter-specimen level differences in radiation among the three PLA+ ukuleles remained at or below 1.7\,dB at all first four identified frequencies. A Hybrid instrument sharing the PLA+ body and cavity but fitted with an Engelmann spruce soundboard was used as a separate material-sensitivity control, departing from the PLA+ group by up to 6.0\,dB at two of the four frequencies, while damping ratios showed no systematic difference between the PLA+ specimens and the Hybrid. These results indicate that additive manufacturing offers markedly high and uniform vibroacoustic reproducibility, supporting its use as a controlled platform for experimental lutherie and acoustic research, within the scope of the two tonewoods and single geometry examined here.