Crop leaves in full sunlight dissipate damaging excess absorbed light energy as heat. This protective dissipation continues after the leaf transitions to shade, reducing crop photosynthesis. A bioengineered acceleration of this adjustment increased photosynthetic efficiency and biomass in tobacco in the field. But could that also translate to increased yield in a food crop? Here we bioengineered the same change into soybean. In replicated field trials, photosynthetic efficiency in fluctuating light was higher and seed yield in five independent transformation events increased by up to 33%. Despite increased seed quantity, seed protein and oil content were unaltered. This validates increasing photosynthetic efficiency as a much needed strategy toward sustainably increasing crop yield in support of future global food security.
We recently demonstrated that accelerating the relaxation of nonphotochemical quenching leads to higher soybean photosynthetic efficiency and yield. In response, Sinclair et al . assert that improved photosynthesis cannot improve crop yields and that there is only one valid experimental design for proving a genetic improvement in yield. We explain here why neither assertion is valid.
Improving photosynthesis is proposed as a means of enhancing crop productivity. To assess whether simultaneous increases in light use‐efficiency and carbon assimilation are additive, we investigated the impact of elevated CO 2 on the performance of a transgenic soybean line engineered for faster relaxation of photoprotection by overexpression of three genes: violaxanthin de‐epoxidase, photosystem II subunit S and zeaxanthin epoxidase (VPZ‐34A). Plants were grown in field plots with and without elevated CO 2. Physiological and transcriptomic measurements were collected during vegetative and reproductive stages and compared to final biomass and seed production. VPZ‐34A showed improved light use efficiency during vegetative growth, but no increase in carbon assimilation, and no increase in seed or biomass‐related traits under ambient or elevated CO 2 concentrations. A small number of genes were differentially expressed in VPZ‐34A, including downregulation of a mitochondrial thioredoxin ( Trx o1 ) and up‐regulation of two AP2 transcription factors, which may suggest alterations in redox balance and seed development. In conclusion, the improvements in light use efficiency by modulating photoprotection did not have an additive effect with elevated CO 2 concentrations and did not stimulate soybean yield in the year measured. Our data highlight the complex relationship between photoprotection, carbon assimilation and yield, and provide avenues for future research.
Improving photosynthetic efficiency is proposed as a means of enhancing crop productivity under rising atmospheric CO 2 concentrations ([CO 2 ]). To assess whether additive gains can be realized from simultaneous improvements in light use-efficiency and carbon assimilation, we investigated the physiological and molecular responses to elevated CO 2 (e[CO 2 ]) of a transgenic soybean line (VPZ-34A) expressing the genes violaxanthin de-epoxidase ( VDE ), Photosystem II subunit S ( PsbS ) and zeaxanthin epoxidase ( ZEP ) from Arabidopsis thaliana (arabidopsis) ( AtVPZ ). Plants were grown at a free-air CO 2 enrichment facility (SoyFACE) in 2021, with physiological and transcriptomic measurements collected during vegetative (V4-5) and reproductive stages (R5-6), then compared to final biomass and seed production parameters. VPZ-34A showed increased maximum quantum photosynthetic efficiency of photosynthesis (φPSII max ) under fluctuating light during vegetative stages, but no increase in maximum efficiency of carbon assimilation (φCO 2,max ), and no significant increase in seed or biomass related traits under ambient or e[CO 2 ]. Transcriptome analysis showed the VPZ construct impacted a small number of genes, among them downregulation of a mitochondrial thioredoxin ( Trx o1 ) and up-regulation of two AP2 transcription factors in VPZ lines may suggest alterations in redox balance and seed development. In conclusion, the improvements in φPSII max and NPQ in VPZ-34A were unaffected by e[CO 2 ] but didn’t translate to stimulation of yield. Our data highlight the complexity of VPZ manipulation on plant performance and provide avenues for future research to optimize this strategy to improve crop yields.