To thrive in diverse environments, bacteria must shift their metabolic output in response to nutrient bioavailability. In many bacterial species, such changes in metabolic flux depend upon lipoic acid, a cofactor required for the activity of enzyme complexes involved in glycolysis, the citric acid cycle, glycine catabolism, and branched chain fatty acid biosynthesis. The requirement of lipoic acid for metabolic enzyme activity necessitates that bacteria synthesize the cofactor and/or scavenge it from environmental sources. Although use of lipoic acid is a conserved phenomenon, the mechanisms behind its biosynthesis and salvage can differ considerably between bacterial species. Furthermore, low levels of circulating free lipoic acid in mammals underscore the importance of lipoic acid acquisition for pathogenic microbes during infection. In this study, we used a genetic approach to characterize the mechanisms of lipoic acid biosynthesis and salvage in the bacterial pathogen Staphylococcus aureus and evaluated the requirements for both pathways during murine sepsis. We determined that S. aureus lipoic acid biosynthesis and salvage genes exist in an arrangement that directly links redox stress response and acetate biosynthesis genes. In addition, we found that lipoic acid salvage is dictated by two ligases that facilitate growth and lipoylation in distinct environmental conditions in vitro, but that are fully compensatory for survival in vivo. Upon infection of mice, we found that de novo biosynthesis or salvage promotes S. aureus survival in a manner that depends upon the infectious site. In addition, when both lipoic acid biosynthesis and salvage are blocked S. aureus is rendered avirulent, implying an inability to induce lipoic acid-independent metabolic programs to promote survival. Together, our results define the major pathways of lipoic acid biosynthesis and salvage in S. aureus and support the notion that bacterial nutrient acquisition schemes are instrumental in dictating pathogen proclivity for an infectious niche. Staphylococcus aureus is a predominant cause of infectious diseases ranging from superficial skin and soft tissue infections to necrotizing pneumonia and sepsis. A remarkable aspect of S. aureus pathobiology lies in the ability of the microorganism to infect a wide variety of host tissues. This infectious promiscuity implies S. aureus exhibits significant adaptability when faced with disparate environments and nutritional deficiencies. In this work, we examine the mechanisms by which S. aureus acquires lipoic acid, a key cofactor involved in maintaining metabolic flux. Our studies determine that S. aureus engages in both de novo biosynthesis and salvage of lipoic acid in a manner that is reminiscent of pathways used by both B. subtilis and L. monocytogenes combined. Further, our work suggests that the complex mechanisms of lipoic acid acquisition dictate the range of tissues S. aureus infects and identifies a lipoic acid salvage enzyme that is dispensable for growth in vitro, but required for S. aureus pathogenesis in vivo. In sum, our results highlight the adaptability of S. aureus in the face of nutrient paucity; the importance of complex nutrient acquisition/biosynthesis pathways in promoting infection; and identify potential novel therapeutic targets that may be effective against S. aureus.