Moving images without sound tend to lack the dimension of embodiment. Music forestalls or remedies this lack; it projects and specifies a lifelike effect of embodiment on behalf of the images. Classical music in particular tends to project an idealized body image characterized as smooth and closed (what Mikhail Bhaktin calls the “classical body”). But it does so only in relationship to a contrary, more porous, sometimes violent mode of embodiment, which may equally reveal itself through classical music. Examples in cinema include Mike Figgis’s The Loss of Sexual Innocence and Jacques Audiard’s De battre mon coeur s’est arrêté (‘The Beat that my Heart Skipped’).
The philosophy and aesthetics of music in the nineteenth century recapitulated the change that overtook music (along with literature, psychology, and medicine) in the century before: the shift of concern from affectivity to subjectivity. Hegel epitomized this shift, and the limitation attached to it, when he posited that music presents the subject with the latter’s own subjectivity, but only in pre-reflective form. For Hegel, the power to articulate subjectivity rested with language, and language, even in song, remained external to music. The idea that this formulation crystallized became the default understanding. It gave rise to two corollaries that would long remain dominant. The first is the idea that music is a vehicle (among the arts, the primary vehicle) of the ineffable and the transcendent. The second—actually the first again negative form—is the idea that music is always fully immediate and cannot, therefore, convey ideas. The music of the era, however—for example in compositions by Mendelssohn, Liszt, Schumann, Nietzsche, and Mahler—often resists both ideas in favor of the possibility that music is capable of reflective understanding.
The aim of this chapter is to examine the encounter between some of the music of black America—ragtime, blues, and jazz—and white modernist concert music in both the United States and France. It intends to show that it is not going too far to describe the results as a continuation of blackface by different means. The original blackface minstrels, were crude, obscene, and egregiously racist, a carnivalesque debasement of the black male as other. The encounter of musical modernism with jazz and blues might be said to have produced a site at which dominant white cultures were unusually hospitable to African-American cultural energies, well in advance of parallel encounters in popular music. The social and cultural motives for giving concert music an Africanist dimension obviously differed by nation. There evolved a body of techniques by which the texture of a concert piece could embed the sounds of black music but at the same time imbue them with an aura of distance. The black sounds function as framed references to the idiom of the other. Musical Africanisms are generally supposed to occupy an ex-centric position, to stand outside the essence of the artwork even as their presence defines the character of the artwork. With the advent of what might be called jazz-age modernism, mainstream musical Africanism can be said to have combined the semiotics of Ives's First Sonata and the structural usage of his “Elegy.” Musical Africanisms arise in the place that pleasure as excess is felt to have vacated.
Inventors in the age of the Enlightenment created lifelike androidscapable of playing music on real instruments. Music and theForms of Life examines the link be...