Previous research indicated that valence of qualitative consumer reviews (positive versus negative) on a mental health therapist’s provider website caused participants to ignore high or low numerical ratings (participants were more influenced by qualitative reviews than by numerical ratings). Our current study extended this research by manipulating the type of commentary presented (experience- or outcome-focused qualitative reviews). Participants reviewed a fictitious therapist’s online profile and indicated their intent to seek professional help, compliance intent, potential bond, and expectations of client health outcomes. Results indicated participants were more sensitive to experience comments than outcome comments when comments were negative.