The article provides a comprehensive scientific analysis of the use of open-source intelligence (OSINT) methodologies as a highly effective tool for combating crime in the context of humanity’s modern transition into the era of total digitalization and the dominance of information flows. It is noted that representatives of the criminal sphere actively use the advantages of cyberspace to coordinate their plans but inevitably leave a specific “digital footprint”. The authors examine in detail the essence of the OSINT concept, which consists of the legal collection, processing, and interpretation of publicly available information. Special attention in the publication is paid to a detailed analysis of specific successful foreign cases of OSINT application. In particular, the process of solving the “Gilgo Beach Murders” serial killings in the USA is analyzed, where a key role was played by a symbiosis of traditional evidentiary techniques (DNA analysis on pizza remnants) and digital intelligence tools: AI-based vehicle recognition systems, Google and Bing Maps geospatial data, as well as the analysis of digital footprints from the accused’s anonymous email. The experience of various US states in combating poaching is investigated, where investigators establish facts of illegal hunting, the use of prohibited feed, and farm trespassing through social media profiling, geotag monitoring, and the analysis of publications by tagged friends of the perpetrators. Of utmost importance is the described experience of countering organized crime in the field of human trafficking using the Memex program developed by DARPA. Furthermore, the authors of the article highlight the powerful preventive potential of OSINT in predicting social unrest, using the example of the events at the US Capitol in 2021, where automated hashtag searches helped identify coordinating influencers and extremist plans, after which the FBI successfully engaged the public in gathering digital media files. The importance of OSINT for customs administrations is separately emphasized for the purpose of identifying smuggling patterns, creating high-risk profiles, and comparing the declared value of goods. A landmark achievement of independent open-source intelligence recognized by the authors is the Bellingcat case regarding the investigation of the downing of flight MH17: a thorough analysis of photos and videos from social networks allowed tracing the route of the “Buk” surface-to-air missile system, which was later verified by the official international investigation. The legal boundaries of applying these methodologies are examined: information gathering is considered legal only if public data is used without violating constitutional rights and with mandatory compliance with the Berkeley Protocol recommendations to ensure the reliability of digital evidence in court. In the conclusion, the authors state that while OSINT is a standardized tool in international practice, its potential is insufficiently unlocked in Ukraine. The critical need to implement advanced OSINT experience and machine learning technologies into domestic practice to combat crime and properly document war crimes in the current conditions is substantiated.