The residual non-aqueous phase liquid (NAPL) within low-permeability lenses of aquifers is a major contributor to “tailing”, a phenomenon that complicates the remediation of NAPL-contaminated sites. A fundamental challenge in addressing this issue is the lack of understanding of the primary controlling factors and underlying effects of NAPL residuals in these aquifer lenses. This study aims to identify the key factors and mechanisms affecting NAPL residuals in low-permeability lenses through a series of experimental approaches. These include soil column simulation experiments on NAPL residuals in various low-permeability lenses, adsorption experiments on aquifer and lens particles, pore mercury intrusion testing, and particle size distribution analysis. The experiments provided valuable data on residual NAPL saturation SR, particle adsorption capacity, particle size, gradation, and pore size and distribution in different lenses. Using a mass conservation approach, the particle adsorption contributed less than 0.5% to the total NAPL residuals, while retention accounted for more than 99.5%, highlighting that retention is the dominant mechanism governing NAPL persistence in these lenses. The mechanism underlying this result was further clarified through an analysis of particle size characteristics. Correlation analysis was conducted to examine the relationships between residual NAPL and macropore porosity (nmax, diameter > 60 μm), mesopore porosity (nmid, diameter = 30~60 μm), and small pore porosity (nmin, diameter < 30 μm). The results demonstrated that mesopores exhibited the strongest correlation with NAPL retention, due to their pronounced capillary action and sufficient storage capacity for NAPL.