Rock rheology and density have first‐order effects on the lithosphere's response to plate tectonic forces at plate boundaries. Changes in these rock properties are controlled by metamorphic transformation processes that are critically dependent on the presence of fluids. At the onset of a continental collision, the lower crust is in most cases dry and strong. However, if exposed to internally produced or externally supplied fluids, the thickened crust will react and be converted into a mechanically weaker lithology by fluid‐driven metamorphic reactions. Fluid introduction is often associated with deep crustal earthquakes. Microstructural evidence, suggest that in strong highly stressed rocks, seismic slip may be initiated by brittle deformation and that wall‐rock damage caused by dynamic ruptures plays a very important role in allowing fluids to enter into contact with dry and highly reactive lower crustal rocks. The resulting metamorphism produces weaker rocks which subsequently deform by viscous creep. Volumes of weak rocks contained in a highly stressed environment of strong rocks may experience significant excursions toward higher pressure without any associated burial. Slow and highly localized creep processes in a velocity strengthening regime may produce mylonitic shear zones along faults initially characterized by earthquake‐generated frictional melting and wall rock damage. However, stress pulses from earthquakes in the shallower brittle regime may kick start new episodes of seismic slip at velocity weakening conditions. These processes indicate that the evolution of the lower crust during continental collisions is controlled by the transient interplay between brittle deformation, fluid‐rock interactions, and creep flow.
1 November 2021 in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
The grain size distribution of deformed rocks may provide valuable information about their deformation history and the associated mechanisms. Here we present a unique set of olivine grain size distributions from ultramafic rocks deformed under a wide range of stress and strain rate conditions. Both experimentally deformed and naturally deformed samples are included. We observe a surprisingly uniform behavior, and most samples show power law grain size distributions. Convincing lognormal distributions across all scales were only observed for samples experimentally deformed at high temperature (1200 °C) and for some mantle‐deformed natural samples. Single power law distributions were observed for natural samples deformed by brittle mechanisms and by samples deformed experimentally in the regime of low‐temperature plasticity. Most natural samples show a crossover in power law scaling behavior near the median grain size from a steep slope for the larger grain fraction to a more gentle slope for the smaller grains. The small grain fraction shows a good data collapse when normalized to the crossover length scale. The associated power law slope indicates a common grain size controlling process. We propose a model that explains how such a scaling behavior may arise in the dislocation creep regime from the competition between the rate involved in the dislocation dynamics and the imposed strain rate. The common departure from lognormal distributions suggests that naturally deformed samples often have a deformation history that is far from a steady state scenario and probably reflects deformation under highly variable stress and strain rates.
Sustained serpentinization of peridotite within the oceanic lithosphere requires effective supply of water to systems that experience continuous expansion of the solid volume. Hence, serpentinization preferentially occurs along ridge axes and in subduction zones where tectonic activity is intense and fracturing helps generating and sustaining the permeability required to connect seafloor-near environments to depth. The slowest mid-oceanic ridges produce little melt leading to discontinuous magmatic activity with very thin to no crust along most of the ridge length and up to 8 km thick crust focused around local magmatic centers. Three types of ultra-slow ridge sections can be distinguished: i) amagmatic, characterized by scarce basaltic crust and deep seismic activity, ii) magmatic, characterized by a thin basaltic crust and intermediate depth seismic activity, and iii) volcanic, characterized by a thick basaltic crust and shallow seismic activity. At amagmatic and magmatic ridge types, aseismic zones are identified above the seismic zone. The lower limit of the aseismic zone along amagmatic sections is thermally controlled and follows a 400-500˚C isotherm corresponding to the upper temperature limit for the onset of serpentinization. This observation suggests that the aseismic zone is significantly serpentinized with ample supply of water to the peridotite-serpentine interface. Based on recorded seismic activity, we estimate the associated rock volume affected by brittle damage for the different ultra-slow ridge types. We show that damage produced by seismic activity sustains pervasive serpentinization along amagmatic and magmatic types, while it is limited in the case of volcanic sections.
Fluid circulation at basin–basement interfaces in rift systems is primarily controlled by brittle fault networks evolution and major interfaces. In the Upper Rhine Graben (Vosges, France), fractured crystalline basement rocks host major geothermal reservoirs, although the relationship between present-day fluid circulation and inherited, relict hydrothermal pathways remains debated. This study investigates the structural and hydrothermal evolution of the Villé Basin (Vosges Massif, France), located on the western shoulder of the Upper Rhine Graben, and provides a natural analogue for fractured basement reservoirs. The Villé Basin exposes the unconformity between the granitic basement and Stephanian sedimentary cover, allowing direct observations of faulted basement–cover interfaces. An integrated approach combining structural field analysis, petro-mineralogical characterization, and geochronological dating was applied to constrain fault activity and fluid circulation episodes. Two main brittle fault systems are identified: (i) An E–W-oriented fault network is pervasive at the basin scale and connects the basement to the sedimentary cover. These normal faults with metric vertical displacements are associated with hematite mineralization, and localized late barite mineralization event, indicating several hydrothermal circulations. Rb–Sr ages on muscovite and biotite suggest fault activity during Carboniferous–Permian times associated with N020°E extensional constrains. (ii) A later N–S-oriented fault network is localized along major basin-bounding faults associated to kilometric vertical displacement related to the formation of the Rhine Graben. U–Pb dating of newly-formed anatase (TiO 2 ) yields Jurassic-Cretaceous ages (142 ± 66 Ma) questioning the activation of brittle N-S faults, low-temperature clay assemblages (kaolinite, illite/smectite, calcite) indicate late fluid circulation during late stages of URG (Upper Rhine Graben) evolution. These results demonstrate that the structural architecture of fractured basement reservoirs is controlled by evolution of fault systems and their episodic (re-)activation. The Villé Basin highlights the importance of structural control when interpreting geochronological data and provides key insights into fluid flow processes relevant to better understand complex geothermal systems of the Upper Rhine Graben.