Several recent initiatives, including the Choosing Wisely campaign by the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation,
1 have focused on directly defining wasteful health care services that provide little or no health benefit to patients. It is challenging, however, to translate evidence-based lists of low-value services generated by such initiatives into meaningful metrics that can be applied to available data sources, such as insurance claims.
2 The value of most services depends on the clinical situation in which they are provided, and administrative data often lack the clinical detail necessary to distinguish appropriate from inappropriate use. Consequently, the number of low-value services that can be reliably identified in claims data may be limited, and the amount of low-value care detected by claims-based measures may be highly sensitive to how the measures are defined.