Colleen E. Patton

Colleen E. Patton

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Colleen E. Patton

North Carolina State University, Raleigh, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
10 May 2024 in Ergonomics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CPColleen E. Patton
Colleen E. Patton
CWChristopher D. Wickens
Christopher D. Wickens
The concepts of automation trust and dependence have often been viewed as closely related and on occasion, have been conflated in the research community. Yet, trust is a cognitive attitude and dependence is a behavioural measure, so it is unsurprising that different factors can affect the two. Here, we review the literature on the correlation between trust and dependence. On average, this correlation across people was quite low, suggesting that people who are more trusting of automation do not necessarily depend upon it more. Separately, we examined experiments that explicitly manipulated the reliability of automation, finding that higher automation reliability increased trust ratings twice as fast as dependence behaviours. This review provides novel quantitative evidence that the two constructs are not strongly correlated. Implications of this work, including potential moderating variables, contexts where trust is still relevant, and considerations of trust measurement, are discussed.

1 September 2023 in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CPColleen E. Patton
Colleen E. Patton
Discretionary automation, or the choice to turn automation on or off, is less studied than dependence on always-present (static) automation, even though discretionary automation is becoming more common in real-world environments. While the influences of dependence on static automation are generally known, it is unclear how they translate to discretionary automation use. Using a dual-task warehouse management paradigm, the influence of workload, trust, and self-confidence were investigated. Results indicated that higher trust in the automation than self-confidence in completing the task manually was a strong driver of automation use, whereas workload of a concurrent task had no effect on use. Implications of this work are discussed.

27 January 2025 in International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CPColleen E. Patton
Colleen E. Patton
BCBenjamin A. Clegg
Benjamin A. Clegg
BDBlake C. Davis
Blake C. Davis
TCTurgay Caglar
Turgay Caglar
CSCaspian Siebert
Caspian Siebert
NBNathaniel Blanchard
Nathaniel Blanchard

19 November 2023 in Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CPColleen E. Patton
Colleen E. Patton
CWChristopher D. Wickens
Christopher D. Wickens
CSC. A. P. Smith
C. A. P. Smith
KNKayla M. Noble
Kayla M. Noble
BCBenjamin A. Clegg
Benjamin A. Clegg
In a dynamic decision-making task simulating basic ship movements, participants attempted, through a series of actions, to elicit and identify which one of six other ships was exhibiting either of two hostile behaviors. A high-performing, although imperfect, automated attention aid was introduced. It visually highlighted the ship categorized by an algorithm as the most likely to be hostile. Half of participants also received automation transparency in the form of a statement about why the hostile ship was highlighted. Results indicated that while the aid’s advice was often complied with and hence led to higher accuracy with a shorter response time, detection was still suboptimal. Additionally, transparency had limited impacts on all aspects of performance. Implications for detection of hostile intentions and the challenges of supporting dynamic decision making are discussed.

6 May 2021 in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
CPColleen E. Patton
Colleen E. Patton
CWChristopher D. Wickens
Christopher D. Wickens
CSC. A. P. Smith
C. A. P. Smith
BCBenjamin A. Clegg
Benjamin A. Clegg
Objective: The ability of people to infer intentions from movement of other vessels was investigated. Across three levels of variability in movements in the path of computer-controlled ships, participants attempted to determine which entity was hostile. Background: Detection of hostile intentions through spatial movements of vessels is important in an array of real-world scenarios. This experiment sought to determine baseline abilities of humans to do so. Methods: Participants selected a discrete movement direction of their ship. Six other ships’ locations then updated. A single entity displayed one of two hostile behaviors: shadowing, which involved mirroring the participant’s vessel’s movements; and hunting, which involved closing in on the participant’s vessel. Trials allowed up to 35 moves before identifying the hostile ship and its behavior. Uncertainty was introduced through adding variability to ships’ movements such that their path was 0%, 25%, or 50% random. Results: Even with no variability in the ships’ movements, accurate detection was low, identifying the hostile entity about 60% of the time. Variability in the paths decreased detection. Detection of hunting was strongly degraded by distance between ownship and the hostile ship, but shadowing was not. Strategies employing different directions of movement across the trial, but also featuring some runs of consecutive movements, facilitated detection. Conclusions: Early identification of threats based on movement characteristics alone is likely to be difficult, but particularly so when adversaries employ some level of uncertainty to mask their intentions. These findings highlight the need to develop decision aids to support human performance.

1 September 2023 in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CPColleen Patton
Colleen Patton
AWAmelia C. Warden
Amelia C. Warden
RPRebecca Pharmer
Rebecca Pharmer
The current experiment examined how the level of exposure to automation of various reliabilities impacts perceptions of reliability and confidence in perceived reliability ratings. Participants viewed images of multicolored Mega blocks presented side-by-side with a recommendation from an automated system indicating whether the images were a match or not. Participants responded whether the automation recommendation was correct or incorrect. The reliability of the automation across blocks was either 50%, 80%, or 90% and participants saw 10, 50, and 100 trials of each reliability. Overall, the level of exposure to the system had no impact on perceptions of automation reliability, or confidence in reliability ratings. Exposure did differentially impact accuracy of automation classification recommendation across the levels of automation reliability. Results also indicated that increases in perceptions of automation reliability increased confidence in the reliability perceptions. These findings have applications for training participants on imperfectly reliable systems.