Nancy Pontika

Nancy Pontika

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Nancy Pontika

Knowledge Media Institute, Open University , Walton Hall, Milton Keynes MK7 6AA, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

10Years (2017-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
20 December 2022 in Quantitative Science Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
TKThomas Klebel
Thomas Klebel
ACAntonia Correia
Antonia Correia
HMHannah Metzler
Hannah Metzler
PKPetr Knoth
Petr Knoth
TRTony Ross-Hellauer
Tony Ross-Hellauer
The need to reform research assessment processes related to career advancement at research institutions has become increasingly recognized in recent years, especially to better foster open and responsible research practices. Current assessment criteria are believed to focus too heavily on inappropriate criteria related to productivity and quantity as opposed to quality, collaborative open research practices, and the socioeconomic impact of research. Evidence of the extent of these issues is urgently needed to inform actions for reform, however. We analyze current practices as revealed by documentation on institutional review, promotion, and tenure (RPT) processes in seven countries (Austria, Brazil, Germany, India, Portugal, the United Kingdom and the United States). Through systematic coding and analysis of 143 RPT policy documents from 107 institutions for the prevalence of 17 criteria (including those related to qualitative or quantitative assessment of research, service to the institution or profession, and open and responsible research practices), we compare assessment practices across a range of international institutions to significantly broaden this evidence base. Although the prevalence of indicators varies considerably between countries, overall we find that currently open and responsible research practices are minimally rewarded and problematic practices of quantification continue to dominate.

17 November 2023 in Science and Public Policy
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
TRTony Ross-Hellauer
Tony Ross-Hellauer
TKThomas Klebel
Thomas Klebel
PKPetr Knoth
Petr Knoth
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
There are currently broad moves to reform research assessment, especially to better incentivize open and responsible research and avoid problematic use of inappropriate quantitative indicators. This study adds to the evidence base for such decision-making by investigating researcher perceptions of current processes of research assessment in institutional review, promotion, and tenure processes. Analysis of an international survey of 198 respondents reveals a disjunct between personal beliefs and perceived institutional priorities (‘value dissonance’), with practices of open and responsible research, as well as ‘research citizenship’ comparatively poorly valued by institutions at present. Our findings hence support current moves to reform research assessment. But we also add crucial nuance to the debate by discussing the relative weighting of open and responsible practices and suggesting that fostering research citizenship activities like collegiality and mentorship may be an important way to rebalance criteria towards environments, which better foster quality, openness, and responsibility.

8 July 2021 in SocArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
TRTony Ross-Hellauer
Tony Ross-Hellauer
SRStefan Reichmann
Stefan Reichmann
NCNicki Lisa Cole
Nicki Lisa Cole
AFAngela Fessl
Angela Fessl
TKThomas Klebel
Thomas Klebel
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
Open Science holds the promise to make scientific endeavours more inclusive, participatory, understandable, accessible, and re-usable for large audiences. However, making processes open will not per se drive wide re-use or participation unless also accompanied by the capacity (in terms of knowledge, skills, financial resources, technological readiness and motivation) to do so. These capacities vary considerably across regions, institutions and demographics. Those advantaged by such factors will remain potentially privileged, putting Open Science’s agenda of inclusivity at risk of propagating conditions of “cumulative advantage”. With this paper, we systematically scope existing research addressing the question: “What evidence and discourse exists in the literature about the ways in which dynamics and structures of inequality could persist or be exacerbated in the transition to Open Science, across disciplines, regions and demographics?” Aiming to synthesise findings, identify gaps in the literature, and inform future research and policy, our results identify threats to equity associated with all aspects of Open Science, including Open Access, Open/FAIR Data, Open Methods, Open Evaluation, Citizen Science, as well as its interfaces with society, industry and policy. Key threats include: stratifications of publishing due to the exclusionary nature of the author-pays model of Open Access; potential widening of the digital divide due to the infrastructure-dependent, highly situated nature of open data practices; risks of diminishing qualitative methodologies as “reproducibility” becomes synonymous with quality; new risks of bias and exclusion in means of transparent evaluation; and crucial asymmetries in the Open Science relationships with industry and the public, which privileges the former and fails to fully include the latter.

14 January 2023 in SocArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
TRTony Ross-Hellauer
Tony Ross-Hellauer
TKThomas Klebel
Thomas Klebel
PKPetr Knoth
Petr Knoth
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
There are currently broad moves to reform research assessment, especially to better incentivise open and responsible research and avoid problematic use of inappropriate quantitative indicators. This study adds to the evidence-base for such decision-making by investigating researcher perceptions of current processes of research assessment in institutional review, promotion and tenure processes. Analysis of an international survey of 198 respondents reveals a deep disjunct between personal beliefs and perceived institutional priorities (“value dissonance”), with practices of open and responsible research, as well as “research citizenship” comparatively poorly valued by institutions at present. Our findings hence support current moves to reform research assessment. But we also add crucial nuance to the debate by discussing the relative weighting of open and responsible practices and suggesting that fostering research citizenship activities like collegiality and mentorship may be an important way to rebalance criteria towards environments which better foster quality, openness and responsibility.

14 November 2017
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PDF file
MCMatteo Cancellieri
Matteo Cancellieri
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
SPSamuel Pearce
Samuel Pearce
LALucas Anastasiou
Lucas Anastasiou
PKPetr Knoth
Petr Knoth

3 March 2022 in MetaArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
NPNancy Pontika
Nancy Pontika
TKThomas Klebel
Thomas Klebel
ACAntonia Correia
Antonia Correia
HMHannah Metzler
Hannah Metzler
PKPetr Knoth
Petr Knoth
TRTony Ross-Hellauer
Tony Ross-Hellauer
The need to reform research assessment processes related to career advancement at research institutions has become increasingly recognised in recent years, especially to better foster open and responsible research practices. Current assessment criteria are believed to focus too heavily on inappropriate criteria related to productivity and quantity as opposed to quality, collaborative open research practices, and the socio-economic impact of research. Evidence of the extent of these issues is urgently needed to inform actions for reform, however. We analyse current practices as revealed by documentation on institutional review, promotion and tenure processes in seven countries (Austria, Brazil, Germany, India, Portugal, United Kingdom and United States of America). Through systematic coding and analysis of 143 RPT policy documents from 107 institutions for the prevalence of 17 criteria (including those related to qualitative or quantitative assessment of research, service to the institution or profession, and open and responsible research practices), we compare assessment practices across a range of international institutions to significantly broaden this evidence-base. Although prevalence of indicators varies considerably between countries, overall we find that currently open and responsible research practices are minimally rewarded and problematic practices of quantification continue to dominate.