25 February 2025 in Physical Review Research
The concept of the irreducible mass ( M irr ) has led to the mass-energy ( M ) formula of a Kerr black hole (BH), in turn leading to its surface area S = 16 π M irr 2 . This also allowed the coeval identification of the reversible and irreversible transformations, soon followed by the concepts of and energy. This new conceptual framework avoids inconsistencies recently evidenced in a repetitive Penrose process. We consider repetitive decays in the ergosphere of an initially extreme Kerr BH and show the processes are highly irreversible. For each decay, the particle that the BH captures causes an increase of the irreducible mass (so the BH horizon), much larger than the extracted energy. The energy extraction process stops when the BH reaches a positive spin lower limit set by the process boundary conditions. Thus, the reaching of a final nonrotating Schwarzschild BH state through this accretion process is impossible. We have assessed such processes for selected decay radii and incoming particle with rest mass 1 % of the BH initial mass M 0 . For r = 1.2 M and 1.9 M , the sequence stops after 8 and 34 decays, respectively, at a spin 0.991 and 0.857, the energy extracted has been only 1.16 % , and 0.42 % , the extractable energy is reduced by 17 % and 56 % , and the irreducible mass increases by 5 % and 22 % , all values in units of M 0 . These results show the highly nonlinear change of the BH parameters, dictated by the BH mass-energy formula, and that the BH rotational energy is mainly converted into irreducible mass. Thus, evaluating the irreducible mass increase in any energy extraction processes in the Kerr BH ergosphere is mandatory. Published by the American Physical Society 2025
25 February 2025 in Physical Review Letters
Extracting the rotational energy from a Kerr black hole (BH) is one of the crucial topics in relativistic astrophysics. Here, we give special attention to the Penrose ballistic process based on the fission of a massive particle μ_{0} into two particles μ_{1} and μ_{2}, occurring in the ergosphere of a Kerr BH. Bardeen et al. indicated that for the process to occur, some additional "hydrodynamical forces or superstrong radiation reactions" were needed. Wald and Chandrasekhar further expanded this idea. This animosity convinced Piran and collaborators to move from a simple three-body system characterizing the original Penrose process to a many-body system. This many-body approach was further largely expanded by others, some questionable in their validity. Here, we return to the simplest original Penrose process and show that the solution of the equations of motion, imposing the turning point condition on their trajectories, leads to the rotational energy extraction from the BH expected by Penrose. The efficiency of energy extraction by a single process is quantified for three different single decay processes occurring, respectively, at r=1.2M, r=1.5M, and r=1.9M. An interesting repetitive model has been proposed by Misner et al. [Gravitation (W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, 1973)]. Indeed, it would appear that a repetitive sequence of 246 decays of the above injection process at r=1.2M and the corresponding ones at r=1.5M and r=1.9M could extract 100% of the rotational energy of the BH, so violating energy conservation. The accompanying article, accounting for the existence of the BH irreducible mass, introduces a nonlinear approach that avoids violating energy conservation and leads to a new energy extraction process.
20 December 2024 in The Astrophysical Journal
The exceptionally low mass of for the central compact object (CCO) XMMU J173203.3–344518 (XMMU J1732) in the supernova remnant (SNR) HESS J1731–347 challenges standard neutron star (NS) formation models. The nearby post–asymptotic giant branch star IRAS 17287–3443 (≈0.6M ⊙), also within the SNR, enriches the scenario. To address this puzzle, we advance the possibility that the gravitational collapse of a rotating presupernova (SN) iron core (≈1.2M ⊙) could result in a low-mass NS. We show that angular momentum conservation during the collapse of an iron core rotating at ≈45% of the Keplerian limit results in a mass loss of ≈0.3M ⊙, producing a stable newborn NS of ≈0.9M ⊙. Considering the possible spin-down, this indicates that the NS is now slowly rotating, thus fulfilling the observed mass–radius relation. Additionally, the NS's surface temperature (≈2 × 106 K) aligns with canonical thermal evolution for its ≈4.5 kyr age. We propose the pre-SN star, likely an ultrastripped core of ≈4.2M ⊙, formed a tidally locked binary with IRAS 17287–3443, with a 1.43 day orbital period. The SN led to a ≈3M ⊙ mass loss, imparting a kick velocity ≲670 km s−1, which disrupted the binary. This scenario explains the observed 0.3 pc offset between XMMU J1732 and IRAS 17287–3443 and supports the possibility of CCOs forming in binaries, with rotation playing a key role in core collapse, and the CCO XMMU J1732 being the lightest NS ever observed.
9 February 2026 in The Astrophysical Journal
Recently, the gravitational-wave (GW) event S241125n, detected by LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA (LVK), has been reported to coincide with a candidate detected by Swift-BAT/GUANO and an X-ray candidate found by the Follow-up X-ray Telescope onboard the Einstein Probe (EP) and confirmed by Swift-XRT. We estimate that the joint false alarm rate for the three candidates is 1/30 yr and that the corresponding false alarm probability (FAP) is FAP triple = 0.037 (1.8 σ ). The coincidence between the GW and GRB could be an interesting test of their origin and open attractive opportunities for multimessenger observations, if they are actually associated. Motivated by this, we propose a theoretical model in which a binary black hole merger occurs within an active galactic nucleus (AGN) disk. The typically massive and significantly kicked merger remnant accretes disk material at hyper-Eddington rates, and the resulting jet could lead to the GRB associated with the GW event. As the jet interacts with the gas in the AGN disk, the shock breakout produces a Comptonized spectrum, consistent with an unusually soft photon index of the GRB prompt emission observed by Swift-BAT following LVK S241125n. Meanwhile, strong absorption and dust extinction of the afterglow by the high column density typical of AGN disks could explain the unusually hard spectrum observed in the X-ray band by EP, as well as the nondetection of an optical counterpart. Our model is predictive, and we highlight the importance of further constraining the orbital eccentricity of the merger and conducting deep-field observations of the host galaxy to test our explanation.
12 June 2024 in Classical and Quantum Gravity
This paper analyzes the feedback of the rotational energy extraction from a Kerr black hole (BH) by the ‘ballistic method’, i.e. the test particle decay in the BH ergosphere pioneered by Roger Penrose. The focus is on the negative energy counterrotating particles (which can be massive or massless) going in towards the horizon, and the feedback on the BH irreducible mass is assessed. Generally, the change in irreducible mass is a function of the conserved quantities of the particle. For an extreme Kerr BH and in the limit , all the reduced transformable energy goes into the irreducible mass (i.e. ), resulting in high irreversibility. The amount of extracted energy from the BH using test particles is much lower than the change of transformable energy. For non-extreme Kerr BHs, the effective potential of particle motion on the equatorial plane in Kerr spacetime is analyzed, and it is demonstrated that the Penrose process can only be undergone by BHs with a dimensionless spin if the decay point coincides with the turning point. Based on that, the lower limit of the change in irreducible mass is provided as a function of the dimensionless spin of the BH. The significance of the increase in the irreducible mass of the BH during the energy extraction process is generally and concisely illustrated by introducing the concept of transformable energy of the BH. The feedback from the Penrose process on the irreducible mass demonstrates the irreversibility of energy extraction and highlights that the total amount of energy that can be extracted from a BH is less than previously anticipated.