23 February 2021 in Current Opinion in Anaesthesiology
Purpose of review: Microaggressions are daily commonplace, subtle behaviors and attitudes toward others that arise from conscious or unconscious bias. Not only can microaggressions affect one's access to power, resources, and opportunity, but they could also contribute to the persistent disparities faced by marginalized groups among healthcare professionals as well as patients. Recent findings: Physicians, especially those in perioperative specialties, commonly have distress during their medical training. Workplace mistreatment, such as discrimination, has been commonly reported by residents across multiple specialties. Microaggressions also impact patient care as they can influence decisions of medical professionals toward a person or group of people. Summary: This review offers education on the correlation of microaggression and unconscious bias to health disparities, provides tools to address microaggressions as a bystander, and outlines processes for institutional improvement.
28 November 2023 in MedEdPORTAL
Graduate trainees from diverse backgrounds may experience discrimination, mistreatment, and microaggressions. While the ability to identify and respond to microaggressions is a much-needed skill for all emerging trainees, limited training workshops exist for residents, especially within perioperative medicine. To embody the principles of diversity, equity, inclusion, and anti-racism (DEIA), we aimed to empower trainees in the perioperative environment with several strategies for addressing microaggressions to bridge this training gap. Based on critical race theory, transformative learning, minority stress theory, and the structural theory of gender and power, this workshop was developed with the primary aim of educating trainees on microaggressions, amplifying the role of allyship, and providing tools to respond to microaggressions as an ally. We used a mixed methods approach to examine participants’ pre/post self-evaluations of microaggression intervention tools and the overall effectiveness of the workshop. The postsurvey captured the experiences of 54 trainees, including 37 of 44 (84%) first-year clinical anesthesia residents and 14 of 24 (58%) surgery residents. The facilitator and course feedback was remarkably positive. Paired t test analyses on participants’ pre- and postsurvey responses demonstrated a statistically significant increase in knowledge of microaggressions. This workshop also significantly increased learners’ self-reported tools for responding to microaggressions. Overall, these promising findings suggest that the strategies presented in this workshop could be applied across other graduate medical education programs. Institutions may wish to customize workshop elements, such as the case scenarios, and the workshop can also be incorporated within a DEIA curriculum.
2 August 2024 in MedEdPORTAL
Despite growing efforts to increase diversity in recruitment and to teach principles of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), representation of individuals underrepresented in medicine continues to fall short. This demonstrates a need for efforts that target the work environment and culture to increase retention alongside existing recruitment initiatives. We designed this interactive allyship workshop with a focus on building skills necessary for being an ally that has been missing in existing allyship curricula. This workshop was led by multidepartmental faculty with experience in DEI training. Participants engaged in a number of interactive activities to reflect on their own identities and privilege and practiced ways to engage in difficult conversations. Prior to the workshop, participants completed a survey that was repeated at the workshop's completion to evaluate their perspective change and understanding of allyship. We also collected responses to a self-reflective exercise during the workshop. Participants included 68 anesthesia and surgery attendees, 53 of whom (78%) completed the postsurvey. Participants strongly agreed that this workshop was important to the workplace and medical training. Themes from the self-reflective exercises included endorsement of sponsorship and mentorship activities, community support, and advocacy. Interactive skill-building activities are important and effective at helping trainees develop as allies. Long-term follow-up is needed to assess longitudinal knowledge retention and translation into behavioral change to create a more inclusive and supportive work environment.
1 March 2024 in The Journal of Education in Perioperative Medicine : Jepm
Providers’ unconscious biases reinforce health disparities through negative direct patient care and interactions with colleagues. We created a workshop grounded in Critical Race Theory and the importance of different intersectionalities to improve medical trainees’ self-assessment of their implicit biases in curated facilitated spaces. A total of 44 UCSF first-year clinical anesthesiology residents (CA-1) (95% response rate) and 23 surgery residents in their research year (77% response rate) participated in this workshop over 4 separate sessions in September 2020 and 2021. Quantitative data from a pre-/post-workshop survey was analyzed via a paired t test to evaluate our workshop's effectiveness. Feedback on efficacy was obtained by coding themes from our survey's open-ended questions. The workshop was evaluated positively by a total of 65 of 67 participants in the post-workshop survey. On a 5-point Likert scale, participants self-reported they agreed that their unconscious biases affect their clinical interactions from a pre-workshop mean of 3.3 (SD ± 1.32) to a post-workshop mean of 3.9 (SD ± 0.87, P = .008). Our findings suggest that this workshop was effective for perioperative residents and can be extrapolated to all residents by tailoring the workshop to their respective work environments.
13 August 2025 in medRxiv
Background: The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) are updating regulations for pulse oximeters to reduce performance disparities linked to skin pigment. We tested common oximeters with current and anticipated regulatory frameworks. We hypothesized that not all oximeters show more positive bias in darkly vs lightly pigmented participants and that few oximeters would ‘pass’ the anticipated FDA regulations. Methods: We used a controlled desaturation protocol to test 34 oximeters across arterial oxygen saturations (SaO 2 ) 70–100% in healthy adults. Based on what FDA and ISO had shared at the time of study design, we studied cohort sizes of ≥ 24 with ≥ 25% of participants being darkly pigmented. We used the subjective Monk Skin Tone (MST) scale and the objective individual typology angle (ITA) derived from a spectrophotometer to characterize skin pigment. The root mean square error (A RMS ), bias (mean of SpO 2 - SaO 2 error), and skin pigment differential bias were calculated. Monte Carlo simulation explored potential impacts of participant selection on device passing. Results: For cohorts of 24 participants, 28/34 oximeters passed 2017 ISO Standard (A RMS ≤ 4%), 22/34 passed 2013 FDA guidance (A RMS ≤ 3%), 21/34 oximeters passed both A RMS and differential bias criteria for anticipated ISO standards, and 1/34 passed anticipated FDA criteria. More devices passed with cohorts > 24. Eleven oximeters had more positive bias in participants with dark vs. light (dorsal finger) pigmentation across 70–100% SaO 2 . Eighteen devices could pass or fail depending on cohorts selected for analysis. Conclusions: Pulse oximeters show variable performance across manufacturers and models. Notably, only some devices show more positive bias in people with darker skin. Anticipated updates to ISO and FDA frameworks yield strikingly different assessments and require refinement of cohort sizes and differential bias criteria. Whether new guidelines will translate into improved real-world performance or reduced health disparities is yet to be determined.
8 December 2025 in Pediatric Anesthesia