20 November 2025 in Thinking Skills and Creativity
17 February 2026 in Journal of Educational Computing Research
AI chatbots have emerged as innovative educational tools and drawn increasing attention from educators and researchers in programming education. Although previous research has highlighted potentials of applying AI chatbots in programming education, there is a lack of empirical evidence to understand the overall effects of using AI chatbots in programming learning as well as the critical factors that influence the effects. To fill this gap, this study conducted a meta-analysis of 32 empirical studies published between 2015 and 2025 to examine the overall effect size of applying AI chatbots on programming learning performance and identify significant moderators. The results indicated a small-to-medium effect on posttest performance ( g+ = 0.538, 95% CI [.202, .873], p < .01) and a medium-to-large effect on practice performance ( g+ = 0.650, 95% CI [.330, .970], p < .001), based on robust variance estimation models. Moderator analyses revealed that research design and AI chatbot-to-student ratio significantly influenced posttest performance. Specifically, true experimental designs demonstrated significantly larger effects than quasi-experimental designs, and a 1:1 chatbot-student ratio was substantially more effective than a 1:N ratio. These findings underscore the potential of AI chatbots in programming education and offer practical insights for optimizing their integration into instructional design.
10 October 2025 in Advance
AI chatbots have emerged as innovative educational tools and drawn increasing attention from educators and researchers in programming education. Although previous research has highlighted potentials of applying AI chatbots in programming education, there is a lack of empirical evidence to investigate and understand the overall effects of using AI chatbots in programming learning as well as the critical factors that influence the effects. To fill this gap, this study conducted a meta-analysis of 32 impirical studies published between 2015 and 2025 to examine the overall effect size of applying AI chatbots on programming learning performance and identify significant moderators. The results indicated a small-to-medium effect on posttest performance (g = 0.491, 95% CI [.266, .717], p < .001) and a medium-to-large effect on practice performance (g = 0.610, 95% CI [.271, .948], p < .001). Moderator analyses revealed that research design and AI chatbot-to-student ratio significantly influenced posttest performance. Specifically, true experimental designs demonstrated significantly larger effects than quasi-experimental designs, and a 1:1 chatbot-student ratio was substantially more effective than a 1:N ratio. These findings underscore the potential of AI chatbots in programming education and offer practical insights for optimizing their integration into instructional design.
28 October 2026 in European Journal of Education
Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is reshaping teaching. Pre‐service teachers' acceptance of GenAI is closely associated with its effective integration into teaching, but traditional models barely capture multi‐stage cognitive and emotional responses from GenAI's human‐like traits. Based on the expanded Artificial Intelligence Device Use Acceptance Model, this study built a three‐stage framework including cognition, emotion and behaviour. Structural equation modelling analysis of 327 Chinese pre‐service teachers showed their strong willingness to accept GenAI. In the cognitive stage, social influence, hedonic motivation and novelty value were positively associated with performance expectancy, while social influence and perceived humanness were positively associated with effort expectancy. Cognitive factors were indirectly linked to acceptance outcomes through serial mediation pathways involving expectancy judgements and cognitive/affective attitudes. Additionally, digital awareness was positively associated with willingness to use GenAI, while facilitating conditions were positively associated with objection to use. Perceived humanness of GenAI, a key cognitive factor, was positively associated with pre‐service teachers' effort expectancy toward its use; their high performance expectancy of GenAI in teaching was the key emotional predictor for positive acceptance. Conclusions provide theoretical basis and strategies for policymakers, managers, normal universities and developers to optimize GenAI's teaching application in China.
16 February 2026 in Science Education