1 February 2024 in Health Psychology
Optimizing multicomponent behavioral and biobehavioral interventions presents a complex decision problem. To arrive at an intervention that is both effective and readily implementable, it may be necessary to weigh effectiveness against implementability when deciding which components to select for inclusion. Different components may have differential effectiveness on an array of outcome variables. Moreover, different decision-makers will approach this problem with different objectives and preferences. Recent advances in decision-making methodology in the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST) have opened new possibilities for intervention scientists to optimize interventions based on a wide variety of decision-maker preferences, including those that involve multiple outcome variables. In this study, we introduce decision analysis for intervention value efficiency (DAIVE), a decision-making framework for use in MOST that incorporates these new decision-making methods. We apply DAIVE to select optimized interventions based on empirical data from a factorial optimization trial. We define various sets of hypothetical decision-maker preferences, and we apply DAIVE to identify optimized interventions appropriate to each case. We demonstrate how DAIVE can be used to make decisions about the composition of optimized interventions and how the choice of optimized intervention can differ according to decision-maker preferences and objectives. We offer recommendations for intervention scientists who want to apply DAIVE to select optimized interventions based on data from their own factorial optimization trials. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
28 July 2024 in International Journal of Eating Disorders
26 October 2021 in Translational Behavioral Medicine
APAngela Fidler Pfammatter
+1
To improve understanding of how interventions work or why they do not work, there is need for methods of testing hypotheses about the causal mechanisms underlying the individual and combined effects of the components that make up interventions. Factorial mediation analysis, i.e., mediation analysis applied to data from a factorial optimization trial, enables testing such hypotheses. In this commentary, we demonstrate how factorial mediation analysis can contribute detailed information about an intervention’s causal mechanisms. We briefly review the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST) and the factorial experiment. We use an empirical example from a 25 factorial optimization trial to demonstrate how factorial mediation analysis opens possibilities for better understanding the individual and combined effects of intervention components. Factorial mediation analysis has important potential to advance theory about interventions and to inform intervention improvements.
1 August 2024 in Psychological Methods
In current practice, intervention scientists applying the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST) with a 2k factorial optimization trial use a component screening approach (CSA) to select intervention components for inclusion in an optimized intervention. In this approach, scientists review all estimated main effects and interactions to identify the important ones based on a fixed threshold, and then base decisions about component selection on these important effects. We propose an alternative posterior expected value approach based on Bayesian decision theory. This new approach aims to be easier to apply and more readily extensible to a variety of intervention optimization problems. We used Monte Carlo simulation to evaluate the performance of a posterior expected value approach and CSA (automated for simulation purposes) relative to two benchmarks: random component selection, and the classical treatment package approach. We found that both the posterior expected value approach and CSA yielded substantial performance gains relative to the benchmarks. We also found that the posterior expected value approach outperformed CSA modestly but consistently in terms of overall accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity, across a wide range of realistic variations in simulated factorial optimization trials. We discuss implications for intervention optimization and promising future directions in the use of posterior expected value to make decisions in MOST. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
31 January 2024 in Prevention Science
Interventions (including behavioral, biobehavioral, biomedical, and social-structural interventions) hold tremendous potential not only to improve public health overall but also to reduce health disparities and promote health equity. In this study, we introduce one way in which interventions can be optimized for health equity in a principled fashion using the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST). Specifically, we define intervention equitability as the extent to which the health benefits provided by an intervention are distributed evenly versus concentrated among those who are already advantaged, and we suggest that, if intervention equitability is acknowledged to be a priority, then equitability should be a key criterion that is balanced with other criteria (effectiveness overall, as well as affordability, scalability, and/or efficiency) in intervention optimization. Using a hypothetical case study and simulated data, we show how MOST can be applied to achieve a strategic balance that incorporates equitability. We also show how the composition of an optimized intervention can differ when equitability is considered versus when it is not. We conclude with a vision for next steps to build on this initial foray into optimizing interventions for equitability.
2 July 2025 in Behaviour Research and Therapy
JÁJavier Fernández Álvarez
+1
More understanding of how internet-based cognitive-behavioral programs (ICBT) for social anxiety disorder (SAD) work could help further optimize treatment. This paper examines the mediational role of knowledge of SAD, negative social cognitions, self-focused attention, avoidance of social situations, and use of safety behaviors in explaining the main components of ICBT for SAD (psychoeducation, cognitive restructuring, attention training, and exposure). In a 24 factorial trial, 464 participants diagnosed with SAD were randomized to 16 combinations of components of a minimally-guided ICBT program for SAD (Shyne) for 8 weeks, allowing us to compare the main effect for the presence of each component (n = 232) against its absence (n = 232). Mediation was investigated using the joint significance test and path analysis of indirect effects. Previous evidence that psychoeducation and exposure are the most active components was replicated. In single mediator models, knowledge gain mediated the effects of psychoeducation, and reduced use of safety behaviors mediated the effect of exposure. Contrary to a priori hypotheses, the effect of exposure was not mediated by avoidance of social situations, although decreased avoidance was significantly associated with better outcomes. Exploratory analysis with multiple mediator models showed that the main effect of exposure was mediated by reduced use of safety behaviors and reduced negative social cognitions. Self-focused attention was consistently identified as an inert mechanism of change. Reductions in use of safety behaviors, avoidance, and negative social cognitions (in this order) are important mechanisms in explaining the effects of psychoeducation and exposure components for treating SAD.