Bivalves are a diverse group of molluscs that have recently attained a central role in plenty of biological research fields, thanks to their peculiar life history traits. Here, we propose that bivalves should be considered as emerging model systems also in sex-determination (SD) studies, since they would allow to investigate: 1) the transition between environmental and genetic SD, with respect to different reproductive backgrounds and sexual systems (from species with strict gonochorism to species with various forms of hermaphroditism); 2) the genomic evolution of sex chromosomes (SCs), considering that no heteromorphic SCs are currently known and that homomorphic SCs have been identified only in a few species of scallops; 3) the putative role of mitochondria at some level of the SD signaling pathway, in a mechanism that may resemble the cytoplasmatic male sterility of plants; 4) the evolutionary history of SD-related gene (SRG) families with respect to other animal groups. In particular, we think that this last topic may lay the foundations for expanding our understanding of bivalve SD, as our current knowledge is quite fragmented and limited to a few species. As a matter of fact, tracing the phylogenetic history and diversity of SRG families (such as the Dmrt, Sox, and Fox genes) would allow not only to perform more targeted functional experiments and genomic analyses, but also to foster the possibility of establishing a solid comparative framework.
24 January 2023 in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
Hox and ParaHox genes (HPHGs) are key developmental genes that pattern regional identity along the anterior–posterior body axis of most animals. Here, we identified HPHGs in tadpole shrimps (Pancrustacea, Branchiopoda, Notostraca), an iconic example of the so-called “living fossils” and performed a comparative genomics analysis of HPHGs and the Hox cluster among major branchiopod lineages. Notostraca possess the entire Hox complement, and the Hox cluster seems to be split into two different subclusters, although we were not able to support this finding with chromosome-level assemblies. However, the genomic structure of Hox genes in Notostraca appears more derived than that of Daphnia spp., which instead retains the plesiomorphic condition of a single compact cluster. Spinicaudata and Artemia franciscana show instead a Hox cluster subdivided across two or more genomic scaffolds with some orthologs either duplicated or missing. Yet, branchiopod HPHGs are similar among the various clades in terms of both intron length and number, as well as in their pattern of molecular evolution. Sequence substitution rates are in fact generally similar for most of the branchiopod Hox genes and the few differences we found cannot be traced back to natural selection, as they are not associated with any signals of diversifying selection or substantial switches in selective modes. Altogether, these findings do not support a significant stasis in the Notostraca Hox cluster and further confirm how morphological evolution is not tightly associated with genome dynamics.
The molecular basis of sex determination (SD), while being extensively studied in model organisms, remains poorly understood in many animal groups. Bivalves, a diverse class of molluscs with a variety of reproductive modes, represent an ideal yet challenging clade for investigating SD and the evolution of sexual systems. However, the absence of a comprehensive framework has limited progress in this field, particularly regarding the study of sex‐determination‐related genes (SRGs). In this study, we performed a genome‐wide sequence evolutionary analysis of the Dmrt, Sox and Fox gene families in more than 40 bivalve species. For the first time, we provide an extensive and phylogenetically aware dataset of these SRGs, and we find support for the hypothesis that Dmrt‐1L and Sox‐H may act as primary sex‐determining genes by showing their high levels of sequence diversity within the bivalve genomic context. To validate our findings, we studied the same gene families in two well‐characterised systems, mammals and fruit flies (genus Drosophila). In the former, we found that the male sex‐determining gene Sry exhibits a pattern of amino acid sequence diversity similar to that of Dmrt‐1L and Sox‐H in bivalves, consistent with its role as master SD regulator. In contrast, no such pattern was observed among genes of the fruit fly SD cascade, which is controlled by a chromosomic mechanism. Overall, our findings highlight similarities in the sequence evolution of some mammal and bivalve SRGs, possibly driven by a comparable architecture of SD cascades. This work underscores once again the importance of employing a comparative approach when investigating understudied and non‐model systems.
An understanding of Branchiopoda’s evolutionary history is crucial for a comprehensive knowledge of the Pancrustacea tree of life, given their close evolutionary relationship with Hexapoda. Despite significant advances in molecular and morphological phylogenetics that have resolved much of the branchiopod backbone topology, a reliable temporal framework remains elusive. Key challenges include a sparse fossil record, long-term morphological stasis, and past topological inconsistencies. Leveraging a Bayesian Inference approach and the most extensive phylogenomic dataset for branchiopod to date, encompassing 46 species and over 130 genes, we inferred a time-calibrated phylogenetic tree. Furthermore, to strengthen the confidence in our divergence times estimation, we assessed the impact of age priors, topological uncertainties, and gene trees which are discordant from the species trees. Our results are largely consistent with the fossil record and with previous studies, indicating that Branchiopoda originated between 400 and 500 million years ago, and the orders of large branchiopods diversified during the Mesozoic. Concerning Cladocera, results remain problematic, with a sharper uncertainty in the diversification time with respect to the fossil record. Though, the jackknife resampling of fossils and the other sensitivity analyses proved our calibration method to be robust, suggesting that the difficulties in obtaining a paleontological-consistent time tree may be hindered by the variability in branchiopod substitution rates and topological instability within certain clades.
The evolutionary conservation of cell types over deep time has long been theorised but remains difficult to demonstrate. Monoaminergic neurons, which produce molecules such as serotonin and dopamine, are central to animal behaviour and cognition, yet their evolutionary origins remain unresolved. Here, we analysed single-cell transcriptomes from 16 metazoan species spanning eight phyla. Using a novel integration method, Orthogroup Recoding, together with experimental validation, we show that monoaminergic neurons form consistent transcriptional clusters across Bilateria. These clusters share a regulatory signature involving conserved transcription factors, including homologues of Fev , Lmx1b , Fer2 , Insm , and Isl , suggesting a common regulatory program. This signature extends beyond the brain including other monoaminergic cells, such as the gut enterochromaffin cells and larval sensory neurons. By contrast, non-bilaterian lineages lack the coordinated expression of the transcription factors and the biosynthetic machinery that regulate monoamine production. Our observations support the existence of a shared set of TFs that define ‘monoaminergic identity’ across in bilaterians.
The tempo of evolutionary change varies widely across the tree of life, with some lineages undergoing extensive morphological diversification while others remain remarkably static. Notostraca, or tadpole shrimps, exemplify the latter, displaying minimal morphological change for hundreds of millions of years. To investigate the molecular basis of this exceptional stasis, we generated high-quality genome assemblies for Triops granarius and Triops simplex. These genomes, combined with data from 18 additional branchiopod species representing Notostraca and Onychocaudata, were employed for phylogenetic reconstruction and time estimation and support the emergence of Notostraca and their general morphology in the Devonian (approx. 390 Ma). We identified genes with significantly reduced rates of protein evolution in Notostraca compared to their more morphologically diverse sister group, Onychocaudata. Functional annotation linked these genes to morphogenesis and development, but we also detected genes with accelerated protein evolution associated with similar developmental processes. Notably, genes undergoing a decelerated evolution in their protein-coding sequences lack signatures of evolutionary constraints in their non-coding regions. In addition, sequence evolution and gene family expansion/contraction dynamics appear decoupled from the rate of protein evolution, suggesting that genes can undergo reduced evolutionary change in one aspect, but not in others. Our findings reveal a complex interplay between genomic and phenotypic evolution and suggest that morphological stasis is maintained by multiple molecular processes rather than by a single, overarching mechanism.