Technical and non-technical skills are traditionally investigated separately in simulation-based surgical training (SBST). Recent literature has indicated an interrelation of these skills, but a clear relationship is yet to be established. This scoping review aimed to identify published literature on the use of both technical and non-technical learning objectives in SBST and investigate how the entities are related. Additionally, this scoping study reviewed the literature with the aim of mapping how publications on technical and non-technical skills within SBST have changed over time. We conducted a scoping review using the 5 step framework by Arksey and O'Malley and reported our results according to the PRISMA guidelines for scoping reviews. Four databases, PubMed, Web of Science, Embase and Cochrane Library, were systematically searched for empirical studies on SBST. Studies within surgical training addressing both technical and non-technical learning objectives and presenting primary data were included for further analysis. Our scoping review identified 3144 articles on SBST published between 1981 and 2021. During our analysis, an emphasis on technical skills training in published literature was identified. However, recent years have seen an immense increase of publications within either technical or non-technical skills. A similar trend is seen in publications addressing both technical and non-technical. In total, 106 publications addressed both technical and non-technical learning objectives and were included for further analysis. Only 45 of the included articles addressed the relationship between technical and non-technical skills. These articles mainly focused on the effect of non-technical skills on technical skills. Though literature on the relationship between technical and non-technical skills remains scarce, the included studies on technical skills and non-technical skills such as mental training suggest such a relationship exists. This implies that the separation of the skill sets is not necessarily beneficial for the outcome of SBST. A shift towards seeing technical and non-technical skills as intertwined may enhance learning outcomes from SBST.
Background: Research suggests that simulation-based surgical skills training translates into improved operating room performance. Previous studies have predominantly focused on training methods and design and subsequent assessable performances and outcomes in the operating room, which only covers some aspects of training engagement and transfer of training. The purpose of this qualitative study was to contribute to the existing body of literature by exploring characteristics of first-year trainees’ engagement in and perceptions of transfer of surgical skills training. Methods: We conducted an explorative study based on individual interviews with first-year trainees in General Surgery, Urology, and Gynaecology and Obstetrics who participated in a laparoscopic skills training program. Informants were interviewed during and two months after the training program. A thematic cross-case analysis was conducted using systematic text condensation. Results: We interviewed 12 informants, which produced 24 transcripts for analysis. We identified four main themes: (1) sportification of training, (2) modes of orientation, (3) transferrable skills, and (4) transfer opportunities. Informants described their surgical training using sports analogies of competition, timing, and step-by-step approaches. Visual orientations, kinaesthetic experiences, and elicited dialogues characterised training processes and engagement. These characteristics were identified in both the simulated and the clinical environment. Experiences of specific skills transfer included ambidexterity, coordination, instrument handling, and visuospatial ability. General transfer experiences were salient in informants’ altered training approaches. Informants considered the simulation-based training an entry ticket to perform in the operating room and mentioned supervisor-trainee relationships and opportunities in the workplace as critical conditions of transfer. Conclusions: Our findings elucidate characteristics of surgical training engagement that can be interpreted as self-regulated learning processes that transcend surgical training environments. Despite appreciating the immediate skills improvements resulting from training, trainees’ narratives reflected a struggle to transfer their training to the clinical setting. Tensions existed between perceptions of transferable skills and experiences of transfer within the clinical work environments. These results resonate with research emphasising the importance of the work environment in the transfer process. Our findings provide insights that may inform the development of training programs that support self-regulated learning and transfer of training from the simulated to the clinical environment.
1 January 2023 in Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development
Introduction: The aim of the study was to assess the surgical case volume of residents before and after simulation-based training in hip fracture surgery provided on demand versus knee and shoulder arthroscopy provided on supply. Materials and Methods: A retrospective analysis of surgical case volume in hip fracture surgery and arthroscopic shoulder and knee procedures 90 days before and after simulation-based training of either procedure. Sixty-nine orthopedic residents voluntarily participating in either simulation-based training. Hip fracture surgery simulation was provided on supply, ie, whenever 1–2 residents applied for the course, while the arthroscopic simulation course was supplied twice yearly. Results: Thirty-four residents participated in hip fracture simulation on demand and 35 residents participated in arthroscopic simulation on supply. The surgical case volume of hip fracture osteosynthesis increased from median 2.5 (range: 0–21) to median 11.5 (1–17) from 90 days before to the 90 days after the simulation-based training on demand. The median difference was 6.5 procedures (p < 0.0003). On the contrary, the surgical case volume in shoulder and knee arthroscopy was low both before and after the simulation on supply, ie, median 2 (0–22) before and median 1 (0–31) after. The median difference was 0 (p = 0.21). Conclusions: Simulation on demand was associated with increased opportunities to perform in the clinical environment after the simulation-based training compared with simulation on supply. Simulation-based training should be aligned with the clinical rotation of the residents. Simulation on demand instead of supply on fixed dates may overcome this organizational issue of aligning training with the opportunity to perform.
Recent studies suggest surgeons rely on both technical (TS) and nontechnical (NTS) skills simultaneously, while others have suggested interdependence of the skills. On a practical level, a correlation between the skillsets is yet to be established. The present study investigates whether a relationship between TS and NTS exists on an overall level and on the level of the individual operating room (OR) team. This cross-sectional single cohort simulation-based study took place during 3-days of laparoscopic interventions. Laparoscopic and OR video recordings were obtained during the interventions. Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) and Nontechnical Skills for Surgeons (NOTSS) scores focusing on the operating surgeons were subsequently assigned, and Pearson's correlation analyses were performed to assess the association between skill sets. The intervention took place at the surgical laboratory facilities for animal research at Aarhus University Hospital. Three surgical teams participated in the study. Each team consisted of 2 OR nurses and 2 surgeons in post graduate year 3 to 5 undergoing specialist training. Participants of each team were recruited from separate sites across the Central Denmark Region. A total 27 operations were carried out, resulting in 63 recordings that were sent for evaluation. Overall, a weak positive correlation (r = 0.336, p < 0.05) was found between OSATS and NOTSS scores. One team showed a moderate positive correlation (r = 0.497 p < 0.05), while correlations for the other teams were nonsignificant (r = 0.338 p = 0.218), and nonlinear (r = -0.036 p = 0.872), respectively. This study demonstrated an overall relationship between TS and NTS for surgeons during laparoscopic surgery in a simulated setting. The correlation on team level was inconsistent, indicating the dynamics of the individual teams may be of essence. A holistic view on surgical skills may be crucial in enabling surgeons to reach their potential in the OR.