2 March 2021 in Physics in Medicine & Biology
BSBaudouin Denis de Senneville
Baudouin Denis de Senneville
Accurate spatial dose delivery in radiotherapy is frequently complicated due to changes in the patient’s internal anatomy during and in-between therapy segments. The recent introduction of hybrid MRI radiotherapy systems allows unequaled soft-tissue visualization during radiation delivery and can be used for dose reconstruction to quantify the impact of motion. To this end, knowledge of anatomical deformations obtained from continuous monitoring during treatment has to be combined with information on the spatio-temporal dose delivery to perform motion-compensated dose accumulation (MCDA). Here, the influence of the choice of deformable image registration algorithm, dose warping strategy, and magnetic resonance image resolution and signal-to-noise-ratio on the resulting MCDA is investigated. For a quantitative investigation, four 4D MRI-datasets representing typical patient observed motion patterns are generated using finite element modeling and serve as a gold standard. Energy delivery is simulated intra-fractionally in the deformed image space and, subsequently, MCDA-processed. Finally, the results are substantiated by comparing MCDA strategies on clinically acquired patient data. It is shown that MCDA is needed for correct quantitative dose reconstruction. For prostate treatments, using the energy per mass transfer dose warping strategy has the largest influence on decreasing dose estimation errors.
20 August 2023 in Physics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology
BSBaudouin Denis de Senneville
Baudouin Denis de Senneville
Deformable image registration (DIR) is a core element of adaptive radiotherapy workflows, integrating daily contour propagation and/or dose accumulation in their design. Propagated contours are usually manually validated and may be edited, thereby locally invalidating the registration result. This means the registration cannot be used for dose accumulation. In this study we proposed and evaluated a novel multi-modal DIR algorithm that incorporated contour information to guide the registration. This integrates operator-validated contours with the estimated deformation vector field and warped dose. The proposed algorithm consisted of both a normalized gradient field-based data-fidelity term on the images and an optical flow data-fidelity term on the contours. The Helmholtz-Hodge decomposition was incorporated to ensure anatomically plausible deformations. The algorithm was validated for same- and cross-contrast Magnetic Resonance (MR) image registrations, Computed Tomography (CT) registrations, and CT-to-MR registrations for different anatomies, all based on challenging clinical situations. The contour-correspondence, anatomical fidelity, registration error, and dose warping error were evaluated. The proposed contour-guided algorithm considerably and significantly increased contour overlap, decreasing the mean distance to agreement by a factor of 1.3 to 13.7, compared to the best algorithm without contour-guidance. Importantly, the registration error and dose warping error decreased significantly, by a factor of 1.2 to 2.0. Our contour-guided algorithm ensured that the deformation vector field and warped quantitative information were consistent with the operator-validated contours. This provides a feasible semi-automatic strategy for spatially correct warping of quantitative information even in difficult and artefacted cases.
25 March 2023 in Medical Physics
BSBaudouin Denis de Senneville
Baudouin Denis de Senneville
Background: Deformable image registration is increasingly used in radiotherapy to adapt the treatment plan and accumulate the delivered dose. Consequently, clinical workflows using deformable image registration require quick and reliable quality assurance to accept registrations. Additionally, for online adaptive radiotherapy, quality assurance without the need for an operator to delineate contours while the patient is on the treatment table is needed. Established quality assurance criteria such as the Dice similarity coefficient or Hausdorff distance lack these qualities and also display a limited sensitivity to registration errors beyond soft tissue boundaries.Purpose: The purpose of this study is to investigate the existing intensity‐based quality assurance criteria structural similarity and normalized mutual information for their ability to quickly and reliably identify registration errors for (online) adaptive radiotherapy and compare them to contour‐based quality assurance criteria.Methods: All criteria were tested using synthetic and simulated biomechanical deformations of 3D MR images as well as manually annotated 4D CT data. The quality assurance criteria were scored for classification performance, for their ability to predict the registration error, and for their spatial information.Results: We found that besides being fast and operator‐independent, the intensity‐based criteria have the highest area under the receiver operating characteristic curve and provide the best input for models to predict the registration error on all data sets. Structural similarity furthermore provides spatial information with a higher gamma pass rate of the predicted registration error than commonly used spatial quality assurance criteria.Conclusions: Intensity‐based quality assurance criteria can provide the required confidence in decisions about using mono‐modal registrations in clinical workflows. They thereby enable automated quality assurance for deformable image registration in adaptive radiotherapy treatments.
6 January 2026 in Physics in Medicine & Biology
Objective . Clinical implementation of deformable image registration (DIR) requires voxel-based spatial accuracy metrics such as manually identified landmarks, which are challenging to implement for highly mobile gastrointestinal (GI) organs. To address this, patient-specific digital twins (DTs) modeling temporally varying motion were created to assess the accuracy of DIR methods. Approach . A total of 21 motion phases simulating digestive GI motion as 4D image sequences were generated from static 3D patient scans using published analytical GI motion models through a multi-step semi-automated pipeline. Eleven datasets, including six T2-weighted FSE MRI (T2w MRI), two T1-weighted 4D golden-angle stack-of-stars, and three contrast-enhanced computed tomography scans were analyzed. The motion amplitudes of the DTs were assessed against real patient stomach motion amplitudes extracted from independent 4D MRI datasets using hierarchical motion reconstruction. The patient-specific DTs were then used to assess six different DIR methods using target registration error, Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), and the 95th percentile Hausdorff distance using summary metrics and voxel-level granular visualizations. Finally, for a subset of T2w MRI scans collected from patients treated with magnetic resonance-guided radiation therapy, dose distributions were warped and accumulated to assess dose warping errors (DWEs), including evaluations of DIR performance in both low- and high-dose regions for patient-specific error estimation. Main results . Our proposed pipeline synthesized patient-specific DTs modeling realistic GI motion, achieving mean and maximum motion amplitudes and a mean log Jacobian determinant within 0.8 mm and 0.01, respectively, similar to published real-patient gastric motion data. It also enables the extraction of detailed quantitative DIR performance metrics and supports rigorous validation of dose mapping accuracy prior to clinical implementation. Significance . The developed pipeline enables rigorously testing DIR tools for dynamic, anatomically complex regions facilitating granular spatial and dosimetric accuracies.
29 January 2025 in Physics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology
Online adaptive magnetic resonance-guided radiotherapy (MRgRT) enables high-precision radiotherapy for esophageal cancer patients but is less feasible due to long on-table times in combination with long-course treatment. In this study, we conducted an in-silico assessment of a simplified online adaptive workflow, Adapt-To-Shape-lite (ATS-lite), in which deformable propagated contours are not modified, and assessed its feasibility. The ATS-lite workflow was simulated for all fractions of nine esophageal cancer patients who had previously received full online adaptive MRgRT with manual contour corrections if needed. The deformable propagated contours were not adjusted. A dose of 41.4 Gy in 23 fractions was prescribed. Intra- and interfraction dose accumulation were performed to evaluate target coverage per fraction and across the entire treatment. For individual fractions, coverage of the manually corrected clinical target volume (CTV) was considered adequate if V95% > 98 % and V90% > 99.5 %. Feasibility was assessed by recording treatment times in the first patients treated with ATS-lite. The ATS-lite workflow provided adequate target coverage over the entire treatment for all patients, with sufficient coverage in 90% of the 177 fractions analyzed. Closer inspection revealed that inadequate target coverage in individual fractions was primarily attributed to enlargement of the manually corrected CTV, rather than poor contour propagation in the ATS-lite workflow. In seven patients, the ATS-lite workflow achieved a median time per fraction of 23 min. The ATS-lite workflow provides adequate target coverage and is feasible for online adaptive MRgRT in long-course esophageal cancer treatments.
24 December 2024 in Physics in Medicine & Biology
Objective. Inter- and intra-fractional anatomical changes during a radiotherapy treatment can cause differences between the initially planned dose and the delivered dose. The total delivered dose can be accumulated over all fractions by using deformable image registration (DIR). However, there is uncertainty in this process which should be accounted for. The aim of this study is to propose a novel metric estimating the spatial distribution of the accumulated dose uncertainty and to evaluate its performance for multi-fraction online adaptive treatments. Approach. We postulate a new metric, the delta (δ) index, to estimate the uncertainties associated with the dose accumulation process. This metric is calculated for each voxel and takes into account the spatial uncertainty in DIR and local dose differences. For the spatial uncertainty of the DIR, the distance discordance metric was used. The accumulated dose and the δ index were determined for ten lung stereotactic body radiation therapy patients. The δ index was complemented by a more understandable metric, the δ index passing rate, which is the percentage of points satisfying the passing criteria in a region. Main results. The spatial distribution of the δ index and the δ index passing rates showed that voxels failing the criteria were predominantly in lower-dose regions. The mean percentage of voxels passing the criterion increased from 65% to 78%, for threshold doses of 20% and 90% of the prescription doses, respectively. Significance. The δ index was postulated to quantify the spatial distribution of the uncertainties associated with the dose accumulation process. The metric gives an intuitive understanding of the reliability of accumulated dose distributions and derived DVH metrics. The performance of the δ index was evaluated for multi-fraction online adaptive treatments, where a case of sub-optimal image registration was identified by the metric.