Margaret Phillips

Margaret Phillips

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Margaret Phillips

Purdue University Libraries and School of Information Studies, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

12Years (2015-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
2 January 2018 in Journal of Electronic Resources Librarianship
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
NJNastasha Johnson
Nastasha Johnson
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
(2018). Rayyan for systematic reviews. Journal of Electronic Resources Librarianship: Vol. 30, No. 1, pp. 46-48.

3 April 2018 in Journal of Electronic Resources Librarianship
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
JLJing Lu
Jing Lu
By Margaret Phillips, Purdue University Libraries and Jing Lu, Purdue Polytechnic Institute, Purdue UniversityNVivo (QSR International, n.d.a) is a software developed by QSR International for quali...

13 July 2023 in Journal of Engineering Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
JRJason Reed
Jason Reed
DZDave Zwicky
Dave Zwicky
AEAmy S. Van Epps
Amy S. Van Epps
Background: Systematic review or systematic literature review (SLR) methodologies are a powerful tool for evidence‐based decision making. The method originated in the medical sciences but has since been adopted by other disciplines, including engineering education (EE).Purpose: We aimed to answer two research questions: (i) To what extent is the SLR research method being applied in EE? (ii) How closely are SLRs published in EE following established reporting guidelines for the methodology?Scope/Method: We searched Inspec, Compendex, and ERIC for engineering‐related SLRs and meta‐analyses (MAs). We included English language papers that contained an explicit SLR search, or where it appeared the methodology was intended by the author(s). We completed a data extraction process for 21 descriptive and quality‐related items, including engineering discipline, which allowed us to identify the EE studies analyzed in this article.Results: This sub‐analysis presents the results of 276 EE‐related reviews. We found the use of SLR/MA methods is growing in EE, with 93% of papers published during 2015–2022. However, we found that authors are not generally following established guidelines for reporting their methods and findings.Conclusions: Not following the best practices for conducting and reporting SLRs can result in the presentation of incorrect summaries and analyses due to missed evidence. Including search experts (e.g., librarians) trained in conducting SLRs can improve review quality. There is also an opportunity for EE‐related publishers to recruit experts trained in conducting SLRs as peer reviewers to participate in evaluating submitted reviews.

1 November 2018 in The Journal of Academic Librarianship
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
AEAmy Van Epps
Amy Van Epps
NJNastasha Johnson
Nastasha Johnson
DZDave Zwicky
Dave Zwicky

1 January 2019 in The Journal of Academic Librarianship
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
MFMichael Fosmire
Michael Fosmire
LTLaura Turner
Laura Turner
KPKristin Petersheim
Kristin Petersheim
JLJing Lu
Jing Lu

29 April 2024 in IEEE Access
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MPMargaret Phillips
Margaret Phillips
JRJason Reed
Jason Reed
DZDave Zwicky
Dave Zwicky
AEAmy S. van Epps
Amy S. van Epps
ABAmy G. Buhler
Amy G. Buhler
WZWei Zakharov
Wei Zakharov
A systematic review is a specialized type of literature review used to collect and synthesize all the available evidence related to a research question. The methods for systematic reviews should be transparent and reproducible so that other researchers can use, replicate, and build upon the findings. Systematic reviews have been published for decades in medical literature where it is necessary to bring together all the studies related to a particular disease or condition for healthcare professionals to make evidence-based recommendations. Conducting systematic reviews has expanded to other disciplines, including education, business, and engineering. The authors of this study conducted a scoping review to investigate how prevalent systematic reviews are in engineering and to what extent engineering authors are following published reporting guidelines. To conduct this study, the authors searched the databases Compendex, Inspec, and ERIC and retrieved 11,588 records. After removing duplicates and applying inclusion and exclusion criteria, 3,066 articles remained in the final data set. The authors then used a checklist of bibliographic and quality-related items to extract data from each of these studies. The findings show that systematic reviews are a popular and rapidly growing methodology in engineering, internationally, but the quality of the studies, in terms of how authors construct and report their methods, is often low, resulting in many studies that are irreproducible and may fall short of the goal of gathering all the available evidence on a topic. The authors include recommendations for engineering authors, higher education administrators, and publishers.