Objective: Next generation sequencing (NGS) has expanded the diagnostic paradigm turning the focus to the growth plate. The aim of the study was to determine the prevalence of variants in genes implicated in skeletal dysplasias in probands with short stature and mild skeletal anomalies. Design: Clinical and radiological data were collected from 108 probands with short stature and mild skeletal anomalies. Methods: A customized skeletal dysplasia NGS panel was performed. Variants were classified using ACMG recommendations and Sherloc. Anthropometric measurements and skeletal anomalies were subsequently compared in those with or without an identified genetic defect. Results: Heterozygous variants were identified in 21/108 probands (19.4%). Variants were most frequently identified in ACAN (n = 10) and IHH (n = 7) whilst one variant was detected in COL2A1, CREBBP, EXT1, and PTPN11. Statistically significant differences (P < 0.05) were observed for sitting height/height (SH/H) ratio, SH/H ratio standard deviation score (SDS), and the SH/H ratio SDS >1 in those with an identified variant compared to those without. Conclusions: A molecular defect was elucidated in a fifth of patients. Thus, the prevalence of mild forms of skeletal dysplasias is relatively high in individuals with short stature and mild skeletal anomalies, with variants in ACAN and IHH accounting for 81% of the cases. An elevated SH/H ratio appears to be associated with a greater probability in detecting a variant, but no other clinical or radiological feature has been found determinant to finding a genetic cause. Currently, we cannot perform extensive molecular studies in all short stature individuals so detailed clinical and radiological phenotyping may orientate which are the candidate patients to obtain worthwhile results. In addition, detailed phenotyping of probands and family members will often aid variant classification.
Heterozygous Indian Hedgehog gene (IHH) variants are associated with brachydactyly type A1 (BDA1). However, in recent years, numerous variants have been identified in patients with short stature and more variable forms of brachydactyly. Many are located in the C-terminal domain of IHH (IHH-C), which lacks signaling activity but is critical for auto-cleavage and activation of the N-terminal (IHH-N) peptide. The absence of functional studies of IHH variants, particularly for those located in IHH-C, has led to these variants being classified as variants of uncertain significance (VUS). To establish a simple functional assay to determine the pathogenicity of IHH VUS and confirm that variants in the C-terminal domain affect protein function. In vitro studies were performed for nine IHH heterozygous variants, to test their effect on secretion and IHH intracellular processing by western blot of cells expressing each variant. IHH secretion was significantly reduced in all mutants, regardless of the location. Similarly, intracellular levels of N-terminal and C-terminal IHH peptides were severely reduced in comparison with the control. Two variants present at a relatively high frequency in the general population, also reduced secretion but to a lesser degree in the heterozygous state. These studies provide the first evidence that variants in the C-terminal domain affect the secretion capacity of IHH and thus, reduce availability of IHH ligand, resulting in short stature and mild skeletal defects. The secretion assay permits a relatively easy test to determine the pathogenicity of IHH variants. All studied variants affected secretion and interestingly, more frequent population variants appear to have a deleterious effect and thus contribute to height variation.