Studies in corporate governance have shown that female directors are less likely than men to secure powerful board positions. In this paper, we suggest that this view oversimplifies how board members recognize and respond to female members’ agency, and that female directors’ appointments to board leadership roles depend on the specific agency profiles they signal through their career backgrounds (e.g., Chief Executive Officer (CEO), Chief Operating Officer (COO), finance expertise, and long board tenure). Using 93,552 director-year observations from 1,947 S&P 1500 firms between 2009 and 2020, we found that the female directors with CEO or COO background experience relative leadership disadvantage compared to male directors, while female directors with finance expertise or long board tenure do not.