This study aims to identify contemporary issues in the formalisation, preparation, and application of the non-normative act (NNA) as an instrument for implementing administrative discretion from a comparative perspective. To achieve the set objectives, a comparative legal approach was employed to analyse the experience of four civil law countries: Kazakhstan, Romania, Ukraine, and Poland. The study draws on three complementary methods: comparative legal analysis, formal legal analysis, and doctrinal interpretation. The four countries were selected based on their shared continental legal tradition and post-socialist heritage, making comparison with Kazakhstan particularly instructive. The analysis centres on four parameters: the legislative definition of the NNA, the limits of administrative discretion, procedural guarantees for the addressee, and mechanisms of judicial review. The findings suggest that in these European countries, the NNA lacks a single, clear legal definition in laws and subordinate legislation. Issues persist regarding blurred boundaries of administrative discretion, the influence of internal instructions, and insufficient procedural guarantees in the adoption of NNAs. Conversely, Kazakhstan’s legislation defines this term, providing a typology that divides NNAs into subtypes. An analysis of the administrative procedure legislation of the three European countries reveals significant gaps.
30 September 2026 in Bulletin of the Karaganda University. “Law Series”
The article examines acts of official interpretation concerning normative legal acts issued by executive bodies of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with particular attention to their place within the system of non-normative legal acts. It analyzes their legal nature, functional purpose, and role in the implementation of legislation. The objective of the study is to clarify the legal nature and functional significance of official interpretative acts and to determine their place within the system of non-normative legal acts issued by executive authorities. The research is based on a formal-legal methodology, complemented by an examination of administrative practice in the adoption of such interpretative acts. Based on the provisions of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Legal Acts” (2016) and the practice of issuing official interpretations by central executive bodies, the study substantiates its conclusions and develops new scholarly propositions. It argues that, although they do not possess normative legal force, acts of official interpretation play a crucial role in ensuring consistency in the activities of public administration and executive bodies and in reducing legal uncertainty in the sphere of public administration.