20 February 2019 in Cybernetics and Systems
This article consists of three parts. In the first part we describe a short history of cybernetics and an effort, which has been undertaken by a group of scientists in the United States and Europe in recent years, to expand the conception of science so that it more successfully encompasses the social sciences. The intent is to aid communication among disciplines and improve our ability to manage social systems. The second part of the article presents an effort in Russia to develop reflexivity theory into a general theory of purposeful, self-developing systems, thus improving our understanding and management of social systems. Understanding Western and Eastern approaches to cybernetics can be difficult because of the very different histories and intellectual traditions of cybernetics in the United States and Russia. The article ends with a comparison of the two approaches to cybernetics, comparing their features side by side. The differences suggest a great potential for ideas from Russian and Western scientists to enrich the further development of cybernetics and science in East and West.
23 November 2011 in Systemic Practice and Action Research
20 October 2015 in Cybernetics and Systems
The management of social and labor systems requires a multidisciplinary perspective. Academic disciplines focus on different aspects of the social change process and use different methods for describing systems. Systems can be described primarily in terms of variables, ideas, groups, or events. All of these methods can be used to create a richer description of the system of interest. This article describes a theory of social change that uses all of these disciplinary methods. Two illustrative cases are presented: adopting quality improvement methods in management in the United States after 1980 and changing social and labor relations in Russia after 1990.
10 December 2023 in Systems Research and Behavioral Science
20 December 2018 in Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences
Understanding the differences between scientific approaches to cybernetics is difficult because of the very different histories and intellectual traditions in Russia and the West, i.e. the U.S. and Europe. This paper, firstly, describes the peculiarities of the Russian style of scientific thinking, considering as an example Alexander Bogdanov’s theory (tectology) in context of the Russian intellectual tradition. Secondly, the paper compares Vladimir E. Lepskiy’s and Stuart A. Umpleby’s theories of cybernetics looking at them through the prism of Russian and American intellectual traditions. Western cybernetics of the second order includes biological and social versions. It arose from “experimental epistemology.” The goal was to understand the processes of cognition on the basis of neurophysiological experiments, as a result of which cyberneticians came to the conclusion that the observer cannot be excluded from science. Biological cybernetics is concerned with how the brain creates descriptions of the world. Little attention is paid to the world since it already is included in the perceptions of the observer. Social cybernetics is concerned with how people act in the world. Theories or descriptions are thought to be less important than appropriate actions. The Russian interpretation of second-order cybernetics develops its social version. The paper concludes that the differences described demonstrate the great potential for ideas from Russian and Western scientists to enrich further development of cybernetics and science in East and West.
15 July 2022 in Cybernetics and Systems
The rapid pace of social and economic change around the world has led to many books and articles on how organizations can change their structures and procedures. People in the fields of systems and cybernetics have been active contributors to this literature. They strive not only to bring together people from a range of disciplines but also to combine the theories, methods and perspectives of many disciplines. The descriptions of new management methods from the fields of systems and cybernetics have broadened the field of strategic planning, introducing ideas not just from business administration and management but also fields such as biology, philosophy and cognitive science. This article seeks to further develop a multidisciplinary theory of social and organizational change that the authors described in previous papers. The article suggests a model for how knowledge from existing disciplines can play a role in the change process and when the traditional disciplines can be most helpful in a process of organizational change. The article describes how two methods—quality improvement and group facilitation—can contribute to social learning.