5 April 2022 in IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering
Context: The pull-based development model is widely used in open source projects, leading to the emergence of trends in distributed software development. One aspect that has garnered significant attention concerning pull request decisions is the identification of explanatory factors. Objective: This study builds on a decade of research on pull request decisions and provides further insights. We empirically investigate how factors influence pull request decisions and the scenarios that change the influence of such factors. Method: We identify factors influencing pull request decisions on GitHub through a systematic literature review and infer them by mining archival data. We collect a total of 3,347,937 pull requests with 95 features from 11,230 diverse projects on GitHub. Using these data, we explore the relations among the factors and build mixed effects logistic regression models to empirically explain pull request decisions. Results: Our study shows that a small number of factors explain pull request decisions, with that concerning whether the integrator is the same as or different from the submitter being the most important factor. We also note that the influence of factors on pull request decisions change with a change in context; e.g., the area hotness of pull request is important only in the early stage of project development, however it becomes unimportant for pull request decisions as projects become mature.
4 July 2022 in Empirical Software Engineering
16 October 2025 in Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction
In the realm of open source software (OSS) development, the resolution of issues is not just a technical task but a pivotal activity that drives ongoing enhancement and secures a project's sustainability. Contributing to issues is the majority form for external contributors to take part in OSS projects. Although the significance of external contributors is recognized, their contributions in issue process still lacks full quantification and clarity, and the correlation between their contributions and the project productivity remains unclear. In response, we propose issue entropy, a novel metric that quantifies the complexity of event sequence in issue process applied to study the external contributions. The metric applies principles of information theory to scrutinize granular details within a project's issue-related activities, providing a unique lens to understand and assess external contributions. To explore the correlation between external contributions and project productivity, we employed issue entropy as a novel way to examine external contributions, and analyzed its correlation with new bugs, commits, and bug fix time, serving as proxies for OSS project productivity. Our findings reveal a strong positive correlation with new bugs, variable relationship with commit volume based on company sponsorship, and significant negative correlation with bug fix time. We also observe the significant interactions between external contributions and other factors, such as project age and the number of files. Moreover, issue entropy offers a new perspective on the health of the OSS project ecosystem, potentially supporting further research and practical applications.