21 August 2025 in Social Science & Medicine
This study examines how social and healthcare structures in Ireland shape the experiences of individuals diagnosed with Lewy body dementia (LBD) and Alzheimer's disease (AD), with particular attention to diagnostic pathways, care access, and social constructions of dementia. Twenty-three participants with mild to moderate dementia resulting from LBD (n = 12) and AD (n = 11) participated in in-depth interviews between September 2022 and February 2023. Using a descriptive phenomenological approach informed by social constructivist perspectives, interviews were analysed to understand how institutional, geographical, and social factors influence experiences of diagnosis, post-diagnostic support, and public awareness. Healthcare structures and social understanding of dementia created divergent experiences for individuals with LBD and AD. While AD participants generally encountered established diagnostic pathways aligned with dominant cultural understanding of dementia as memory loss, LBD participants faced structural barriers due to complex symptomatology and limited specialist knowledge. Geographic inequalities in accessing specialised diagnostic services particularly affected rural LBD participants. Post-diagnosis, LBD participants encountered greater institutional barriers in accessing appropriate support, reflecting systemic gaps in service provision. Both groups highlighted how societal misconceptions about dementia shaped their lived experiences, with LBD participants particularly affected by the cultural dominance of the Alzheimer's narrative. This study demonstrates how social structures, healthcare systems, and cultural understandings of dementia create inequitable experiences for individuals with different forms of dementia in Ireland. Findings highlight the need for structural changes in healthcare delivery, increased professional education about LBD, and broader societal awareness to address these disparities.
18 February 2026 in Social Science & Medicine
Capability measures offer theoretical advantages for assessing wellbeing in health economics and outcomes research, yet their feasibility for self-reporting by people living with dementia remains to be established. This exploratory study compares the feasibility of self-reporting on capability versus health-focused quality of life measures among people living with mild-tomoderate dementia, using response process validation. Twenty-three community-dwelling participants living with Alzheimer's disease (n = 11) or Lewy body dementia (n = 12) completed four measures using concurrent think-aloud cognitive interviewing: two capability measures (ICECAP-O, ICECAP-SCM) and two health-focused measures (QoL-AD, and AQoL-4D). Errors were coded using Tourangeau's four-stage response model (comprehension, retrieval, judgement, response). Completion times, support requirements, and error patterns were compared across measures and diagnostic groups. Capability measures showed higher error rates (13.7-18.3%) than health-related measures (5.1-8.4%) despite shorter completion times. Comprehension errors (51.2% of all errors) were most common across all measures, particularly for abstract concepts like dignity and doing things that make you feel valued. Retrieval errors were rare (4.9%), suggesting memory is not the primary barrier. Diagnostic groups showed distinct error profiles. Participants living with Lewy body dementia showed higher rates of comprehension errors (57.4% vs 42.9%), whilst participants living with Alzheimer's disease showed more response-selection difficulties (25.7% vs 14.9%). While self-reporting remains feasible in mild-to-moderate Alzheimer's disease and Lewy body dementia, capability measures pose greater cognitive demands than health-focused measures, primarily due to comprehension of abstract concepts and distinguishing capability from functioning rather than memory retrieval. Measures should be validated for specific dementia subtypes, and hybrid approaches anchoring capability judgements in concrete experiences warrant exploration. This exploratory study provides preliminary response process validity evidence to inform measure selection in dementia research and clinical practice, ensuring people living with dementia can meaningfully participate in health economics and policy decisions that affect their care.