Background: Mechanical restraint (MR) remains one of the most controversial interventions in psychiatry, particularly in involuntarily admitted patients. This study examined the prevalence and clinical predictors of MR in an open-door psychiatric unit in Spain, a context where national MR rates remain among the highest in Europe. Methods: A retrospective descriptive study of all involuntarily admitted patients (n = 81) was conducted in a 20-bed open-door acute psychiatric unit between June and December 2024. Sociodemographic, diagnostic, and treatment variables were extracted from electronic health records. Bivariate analyses based on exact tests and Firth penalized-likelihood logistic regression were used to identify independent correlates of MR. Results: MR was applied in 14.8% of patients. In Firth penalized-likelihood multivariable analysis, schizophrenia was the strongest independent correlate of MR (odds ratio [OR] = 9.58, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.71–65.89, p = 0.010). Male gender showed a significant bivariate association but lost significance after adjustment. MR co-occurred with intramuscular psychotropic medication in 91.7% of cases. Conclusions: Within this single-centre, exclusively involuntary cohort, care delivered in an open-door setting with structured de-escalation interventions was associated with a comparatively low rate of MR. Schizophrenia emerged as the strongest correlate of MR and may represent a priority target for prevention strategies. The results align with convergent evidence from German, Swiss, and Norwegian studies supporting the safety and effectiveness of open-door approaches, and provide the first Spanish data on MR in this model of care. These findings are preliminary and require confirmation in larger, multicentre samples.
Introduction Open-door policies for acute inpatient mental health units (AIMHU) have shown promising results in reducing coercive measures, but concerns remain among patients and staff regarding increased workload, constant surveillance, and potential safety risks associated with these policies. Objectives This study aims to develop a monitoring tool to facilitate safety management in AIMHUs by monitoring behavioural risks and nursing workload. Methods This study employed a qualitative approach using the content analysis method. Data were collected through three in-depth interviews and two focus groups involving staff (n=19) from the AIMHU of the hospital. Results 34 items were identified to define behavioural risks related to self-harm and suicide, aggressiveness, and absconding, alongside factors affecting nursing workload. These items were categorised into three levels of risk: low, moderate, and high. Conclusions The result is a risk monitoring tool based on observational items for daily use in AIMHU that can help to reduce the uncertainty about risk management, especially in open-door units. This innovative tool enables individualized patient monitoring, provides insights into the unit’s status, prioritizes conflict prevention, and upholds the human rights of patients.
Purpose Mechanical restraint (MR) remains one of the most controversial interventions in psychiatry, particularly in involuntarily admitted patients. This study examined the prevalence and clinical predictors of MR in an open-door psychiatric unit in Spain, a context where national MR rates remain among the highest in Europe. Methods A retrospective descriptive study of all involuntarily admitted patients (n = 81) was conducted in a 20-bed open-door acute psychiatric unit between June and December 2024. Sociodemographic, diagnostic, and treatment variables were extracted from electronic health records. Bivariate analyses and multivariate logistic regression were used to identify independent predictors of MR. Results MR was applied in 14.8% of patients, representing a approximately 60% reduction compared with the Spanish national average of 37% reported in multicentre European data. In multivariate analysis, schizophrenia spectrum disorder was the strongest independent predictor (OR = 12.29, 95% CI: 1.75–86.46, p = 0.012). Male gender showed a significant bivariate association but lost significance after adjustment. MR co-occurred with intramuscular psychotropic medication in 91.7% of cases. Conclusions Even within a high-risk, 100% involuntary population, open-door policies combined with structured de-escalation interventions can substantially reduce MR use. Schizophrenia spectrum disorders emerge as a critical target for prevention strategies. These findings align with convergent evidence from German, Swiss, and Norwegian studies supporting the safety and effectiveness of open-door approaches, and provide the first Spanish data on MR in this model of care.