In a digital media environment where content distribution is shaped by technology companies’ algorithms and user behaviors, news organizations try to post content that can prompt user engagement in forms such as comments, shares, and likes or reactions. This study employs a content analysis of 1,600 messages and analyses of engagement metrics for 157,962 messages to examine to what extent and how Facebook messages of US and Israeli news organizations differ in the engagement modes they generate: commenting versus sharing versus liking/reacting. Drawing on the participation paradigm in audience research, news value theory, and literature on engagement enhancers, the study shows that certain content characteristics are associated with each of the examined engagement modes in more than one country while other content characteristics are associated with particular modes, but not with all of them. It offers a nuanced understanding of user interaction with news-related content and helps think about content units as more engaging or less engaging than others, or as engaging in different ways.
Uncivil user comments have been found to have a negative effect on how people perceive an issue featured in the news, a news story, or a journalist who reports a news story. To advance this line of research, we draw on expectancy violations theory and the concept of heuristic cues to theorize the toxic atmosphere effect . We theorize that incivility in online comment threads could pose an even larger challenge to news organizations by cuing news audience members to perceive an entire news outlet—not just an individual story—as lacking in credibility. Based on two experiments in the United States (Study 1, n = 520; Study 2, n = 1056), we show that exposure to incivility can lead people to perceive a news outlet as less credible even though the incivility did not directly attack the news outlet. Such effects hold true even when people are exposed to comment threads in which the first several comments are civil. Democratic and business implications are discussed.
The digital environment is dominated by platforms non-proprietary to the news media, such as Facebook and Twitter. On these platforms, news organizations occupy what is termed here triple-party news-spaces: digital spaces that involve a news publisher, a platform owner, and users. Drawing on 28 interviews with professionals working for 14 news organizations in the U.S. and Israel, this study offers a framework for understanding the underlying logics of media production in triple-party news-spaces. It does so while building on the theoretical construct of media logics and the notion of a hybrid media system. Under the proposed framework, the production logics comprise five dimensions: item selection, temporality considerations, hierarchy considerations, expression style, and approach toward UGC. The study reveals what norms are applied and how—along each dimension and in different national/cultural contexts. It thereby advances understanding of news organizations’ activity on platforms that play a key role in distributing digital content.
24 January 2025 in Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
Beyond digital news consumption, users may express themselves in relation to the consumed news—for example, through commenting, sharing, or reacting. They may also limit what is termed here news engagement visibility, the extent to which a user’s involvement with news content can be seen by others. Drawing on privacy calculus theory and literature about engagement, avoidance, and relationship management, this study examines—through 50 in-depth interviews in Canada—how and why news users limit their news engagement visibility. It presents three ways for limiting this visibility, including lower expression volume, more private expression space, or more closed-ended expression type. Furthermore, it introduces the four P’s framework—protection, pointlessness, personality, and particularity—to explain the reasons behind limited news engagement visibility. The study advances the understanding of news engagement by suggesting that it involves the management of visibility boundaries and by elucidating barriers to public expression. The implications of these contributions are discussed.
Second-level agenda-setting suggests that news media influence how we think. As a case study examining the nature and effects of mainstream news media’s coverage of the 2015 Apple/FBI dispute about data privacy versus national security, this study found via content analysis that a majority of articles covering the dispute (73.7%) made the same potentially misleading claim about how the American public feels about the dispute. Nearly half (45.6%) of those articles made public opinion claims without offering empirical evidence, and almost all articles (97.4%) that cited the Pew survey appeared to have inadvertently created an unsubstantiated social reality. Then, this study found in a subsequent experiment that, consistent with impersonal influence, the above-mentioned news portrayals significantly affected the participants’ view on Americans’ collective opinion towards the Apple/FBI dispute. The long-term effect of this journalistic oversight is notable. Theoretical implications and practical recommendations for future science communication in the news are discussed.