Individual and joint malingering detection accuracy of the Portland Digit Recognition Test (PDRT), Test of Memory Malingering (TOMM), and Word Memory Test (WMT) was examined in traumatic brain injury (TBI; 43 non-malingering, 27 malingering) and chronic pain (CP; 42 non-malingering, 58 malingering) using a known-groups design. At published cutoffs, the PDRT and TOMM were very specific but failed to detect about 50% of malingerers; the WMT was sensitive but prone to false positive errors. ROC analyses demonstrated comparable accuracy across all three tests. Joint classification accuracy was superior to that of the individual tests. Clinical and research implications are discussed.
1 October 2006 in Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology
This study used a known-groups design to determine the classification accuracy of the Test of Memory Malingering ( Tombaugh, 1996 Tombaugh, T. 1996. Test of Memory Malingering manual, New York: MultiHealth Systems. [Google Scholar] , 1997 Tombaugh, T.N. 1997. The Test of Memory Malingering (ToMM): Normative data from cognitively intact and cognitively impaired individuals. Psychological Assessment, 9: 260–68. [CROSSREF] [CSA] [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] ) in detecting cognitive malingering in traumatic brain injury (TBI). Forty-one of 161 TBI patients met Slick, Sherman, and Iverson (1999) Slick, D.J. , Sherman, E.M.S. and Iverson, G.L. 1999. Diagnostic criteria for malingering neurocognitive dysfunction: Proposed standards for clinical practice and research. The Clinical Neuropsychologist, 13: 545–561. [INFOTRIEVE] [CSA] [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] criteria for Malingered Neurocognitive Dysfunction. Twenty-two no-incentive memory disorder patients were also included. The original cutoffs (<45) for Trial 2 and Retention demonstrated excellent specificity (less than a 5% false positive error rate) and impressive sensitivity (greater than 45%). However, these cutoffs are actually conservative in the context of mild TBI. Over 90% of the non-MND mild TBI sample scored 48 or higher on the Retention Trial and none scored less than 46 while 60% of the MND patients claiming mild TBI were detected at those levels. Trial 1 also demonstrated excellent classification accuracy. Application of these data to clinical practice is discussed.
1 July 2009 in Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
The present study used a known-groups design to determine the classification accuracy of 10 MMPI-2 validity scales and indicators in the detection of cognitive malingering in traumatic brain injury. Participants were 259 traumatic brain injury and 133 general clinical patients seen for neuropsychological evaluation. The TBI patients were subdivided into groups based on a comprehensive examination of effort following Slick, Sherman, and Iverson's ( 1999 Slick , D. J. , Sherman , E. M. S. , & Iverson , G. L. ( 1999 ). Diagnostic criteria for malingering neurocognitive dysfunction: Proposed standards for clinical practice and research . The Clinical Neuropsychologist , 13 , 545 – 561 . [INFOTRIEVE] [CSA] [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] ) criteria. More extreme scores demonstrated excellent specificity; often impressive sensitivity was seen even while maintaining a low false positive error rate. Specificity was good even in stroke, memory disorder, and psychiatric patients without incentive. The results of this study are presented in frequency tables that can be easily referenced in clinical practice.
The purpose of this study was to determine if there is a dose-response relationship between potential monetary compensation and failure on psychological indicators of malingering in traumatic brain injury. 332 traumatic brain injury patients were divided into three groups based on incentive to perform poorly on neuropsychological testing: no incentive; limited incentive as provided by State law; high incentive as provided by Federal law. The rate of failure on five well-validated malingering indicators across these groups was examined. Cases handled under Federal workers compensation laws showed considerably higher rates of failure and diagnosable malingering than cases handled under State law. The findings indicate that monetary compensation associated with workers compensation claims is a major motive for exaggeration and malingering of problems attributed to work-related brain injuries. The clinician's index of suspicion regarding exaggeration and malingering of symptoms and deficits should be much higher in the context of Federal workers compensation claims, particularly in patients who have suffered only mild traumatic brain injury.
1 October 2006 in Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology
Pain patients often report cognitive symptoms and many will include them in their claims of disability. The Processing Speed Index (PSI) of the WAIS-III was investigated as one aspect of cognitive functioning in six groups. Slight impairment was found for PSI and Digit Symbol subtest performance, but not for Symbol Search, in a Laboratory-induced Pain group and a Clinical Pain group. The lowest scores were found in a Simulator group instructed to fake cognitive impairment and a Clinical Pain group diagnosed as Malingering. Results suggest that PSI scores are only slightly reduced by laboratory-induced pain or chronic pain, and that unexpectedly low scores in the absence of significant/documented brain dysfunction suggest poor effort or deliberate misrepresentation.