13 January 2022 in Climate Policy
The production of iron and steel is one of the largest global sources of industrial greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. South Africa (SA) could competitively export near-zero embodied GHG primary iron to steelmakers in leading decarbonizing markets. A green primary iron production process substitutes hydrogen for coke as the iron ore reductant. A SA plant would enjoy most of its competitive cost advantage from hydrogen produced using very low-cost solar photovoltaic electricity. In import markets, using the European Union (EU) as an example, steelmakers could use imported green primary iron to increase utilization of electric arc furnaces while reducing total EU demand for clean electricity (i.e. for hydrogen for reduction needs) and thereby lower total system costs of decarbonization. SA could bolster crucial export and tax revenues while moving towards a broader transition to a sustainable industry. Three things are needed to unlock new global business models involving the relocating of green primary iron production to regions with abundant renewable energy: (1) a steelmaker with access to a hydrogen reduction technology appropriate for SA’s ores willing and able to invest in a plant; (2) access to a bankable lead market for that plant’s production; and (3) international trade rules and emissions accounting related to the carbon content of commodities that enable the reconfiguration of supply chains to reduce global decarbonization costs.
15 March 2023 in Climate Policy
Working with in-country modelling teams and models, targeting net-zero CO2 emissions by later this century, and using decomposition and emissions driver analysis, we develop low emissions cement and steel scenarios linked to usable policy levers for Brazil, India, and South Africa. We find significant mitigation potential from a ‘current policy’ scenario on the demand side (13–26%) and the production side (58–71%), but these countries’ substantial needs for more basic infrastructure – and thus for cement and steel inputs – indicate net-zero will remain very challenging. Demand-side material efficiency reductions, where less steel and cement deliver the same service through better design, will require decades of educational and regulatory efforts, working with buildings sector and infrastructure supply chain actors to reach full potential. In the short to medium run, focusing on reducing emissions from production may deliver more near-term cumulative mitigation by allowing close attention to a small number of domestic companies with high managerial, technical, and financial capacity. To achieve such reductions, governments should encourage the concentration of cement and concrete making at professional facilities to allow the use and regulation of already commercialized lower GHG practices like cementitious material clinker replacement and better concrete mixing while planning for future carbon capture and storage. Governments should also encourage investment in secondary steel making using electric arc furnaces to reuse local recycled scrap, eventually supplemented with increasingly low emission primary iron. International cooperation and support are needed to agree on and implement CO2 intensity accounting systems, improve access to low-emissions production technologies through innovation and commercialization combined with technology transfer or co-development, and offer financial and technical support for clean production investments. Key policy insights