This article analyzes the role of STEM initiatives designed by city and corporate elites in a large urban district and outlines an alternative, grassroots vision for (STEM) education and city schools. Within a neoliberal context of gentrification, displacement, disinvestment, and privatization, STEM schools have become strategic components of Chicago’s ‘portfolio district’ that serve the interests of racial capitalism in three ways. First, STEM schools provide a claim to fairness in the midst of racist school closures. Second, STEM high schools are a corporate strategy for racially stratified labor force preparation that restricts curriculum and reifies tracking. Third, curriculum restriction prioritizes corporate interests over students’ capacity to shape their communities and the world. The authors draw on the wisdom of Chicago communities who have led resistance against corporate education reform to critique Chicago STEM policy and point to critical mathematics and science education as part of a model for sustainable community schools.
This article introduces Youth Participatory Science (YPS) as an approach to science teaching and grassroots knowledge production that draws from traditions of youth participatory action research (YPAR) and citizen science. YPS is differentiated from YPAR by its emphasis on the tools and methods of the so-called natural sciences while it extends citizen science in important ways by prioritizing youth, pedagogy, and democratizing participation in all phases of knowledge production. This article contributes to a conceptual definition of YPS and articulates the affordances and limitations of distinguishing it from YPAR and citizen science. It then introduces a curriculum framework that synthesizes approaches to planning for critical pedagogy and science education with the intention of supporting teachers to navigate the barriers to enacting YPS in secondary science classrooms.
7 March 2019 in Cultural Studies of Science Education