Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are advanced core-shell particles for messenger RNA (mRNA) based therapies that are made of polyethylene glycol (PEG) lipid, distearoylphosphatidylcholine (DSPC), cationic ionizable lipid (CIL), cholesterol (chol), and mRNA. Yet the mechanism of pH-dependent response that is believed to cause endosomal release of LNPs is not well understood. Here, we show that eGFP (enhanced green fluorescent protein) protein expression in the mouse liver mediated by the ionizable lipids DLin-MC3-DMA (MC3), DLin-KC2-DMA (KC2), and DLinDMA (DD) ranks MC3 ≥ KC2 > DD despite similar delivery of mRNA per cell in all cell fractions isolated. We hypothesize that the three CIL-LNPs react differently to pH changes and hence study the structure of CIL/chol bulk phases in water. Using synchrotron X-ray scattering a sequence of ordered CIL/chol mesophases with lowering pH values are observed. These phases show isotropic inverse micellar, cubic Fd3m inverse micellar, inverse hexagonal and bicontinuous cubic Pn3m symmetry. If polyadenylic acid, as mRNA surrogate, is added to CIL/chol, excess lipid coexists with a condensed nucleic acid lipid phase. The next-neighbor distance in the excess phase shows a discontinuity at the Fd3m inverse micellar to inverse hexagonal transition occurring at pH 6 with distinctly larger spacing and hydration for DD vs. MC3 and KC2. In mRNA LNPs, DD showed larger internal spacing, as well as retarded onset and reduced level of DD-LNP-mediated eGFP expression in vitro compared to MC3 and KC2. Our data suggest that the pH-driven Fd3m- transition in bulk phases is a hallmark of CIL-specific differences in mRNA LNP efficacy.
Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are efficient and safe carriers for mRNA vaccines based on advanced ionizable lipids. It is understood that the pH-dependent structural transition of the mesoscopic LNP core phase plays a key role in mRNA transfer. However, buffer-specific variations in transfection efficiency remain obscure. Here we analyze the effect of the buffer type on the transfection efficiency of LNPs. We find that LNPs formulated with the cationic ionizable lipids DLin-MC3-DMA (MC3), SM-102, and ALC-315 in citrate compared to phosphate and acetate buffers exhibit earlier onset and stronger mRNA-GFP expression in vitro. Using synchrotron small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) we determine the buffer specificity of the pH-dependent structure of ionizable lipid/cholesterol/water mesophases that serve as model systems for the LNP core phase. The results show that the phase transition from inverse micellar to inverse hexagonal with decreasing pH is shifted to a lower transition pH for acetate and phosphate compared with citrate buffer. Based on continuum theory and ion-specific adsorption obtained from all-atom MD simulations, we propose a mechanism for buffer specificity. Citrate stabilizes the inverse hexagonal phase thus shifting the formation of HII to a higher pH. By contrast, phosphate and acetate stabilize LII. It stands to reason that the inverse micellar to inverse hexagonal transition, which is facilitated in citrate buffer, enables a sensitized pH response of the LNP core phase. This, in turn, enhances endosomal release efficiency and accounts for the earlier onset of gene expression observed in LNPs prepared with citrate buffer.
20 October 2023 in The Journal of Chemical Physics
The pH-dependent change in protonation of ionizable lipids is crucial for the success of lipid-based nanoparticles as mRNA delivery systems. Despite their widespread application in vaccines, the structural changes upon acidification are not well understood. Molecular dynamics simulations support structure prediction but require an a priori knowledge of the lipid packing and protonation degree. The presetting of the protonation degree is a challenging task in the case of ionizable lipids since it depends on pH and on the local lipid environment and often lacks experimental validation. Here, we introduce a methodology of combining all-atom molecular dynamics simulations with experimental total-reflection x-ray fluorescence and scattering measurements for the ionizable lipid Dlin-MC3-DMA (MC3) in POPC monolayers. This joint approach allows us to simultaneously determine the lipid packing and the protonation degree of MC3. The consistent parameterization is expected to be useful for further predictive modeling of the action of MC3-based lipid nanoparticles.