Climatic conditions fundamentally shape building energy loads, yet their influence on energy benchmarking outcomes in certified buildings is often treated implicitly or through coarse climate zoning. This study examines how long-term climatic factors are associated with the achievement of the Optimize Energy Performance credit (EA7) in LEED v4 New Construction projects across the United States. A dataset of 779 certified buildings was analyzed using spatially matched climatological variables, including heating and cooling degree days, solar resource availability, precipitation, wind speed, temperature, and humidity, derived from high-resolution datasets. To capture both interpretable and non-linear climate-energy relationships, a multi-method framework integrating multiple linear regression, Random Forest regression, and hierarchical clustering was employed. Across methods, results consistently show that moisture- and load-related factors, particularly precipitation and wind exposure, are dominant negative correlates of EA7 achievement, while global tilted irradiance is a strong positive contributor. Cooling demand exhibits a modest negative association, whereas heating demand and mean temperature play comparatively limited roles once multiple climatic variables are considered jointly. Random Forest models substantially outperform linear regression, indicating non-linear interactions and threshold effects in climate-energy relationships. Clustering further identifies two distinct climate-performance regimes, separating solar-rich, low-load environments from wetter, wind-exposed climates with systematically lower EA7 outcomes. These findings demonstrate that identical energy credit scores can reflect markedly different levels of technical difficulty under varying climatic conditions. Explicitly linking climate metrics to modeled energy performance outcomes advances climate-aware interpretation of benchmarking results and supports more physically grounded evaluation of building energy performance across regions.