A structural interpretation of institutionalism has become dominant in public management research. Yet, studies tend to assume an institutional-level phenomenon without specifying how an organizational field was identified or whether structural characteristics can indeed be found in the organizational population studied. This lacuna is illustrated by exploring the structural interpretation of the field construct in the case of the recent overhaul of English primary care. Findings demonstrate the need for a more robust application of institutionalism in empirical research. Possible research problems for public management and a future research agenda based on a more relational approach to fields are discussed.
1 August 2013 in Technology Analysis & Strategic Management
During the last two decades, policymakers in various positions have been adopting a systems-approach to policy thinking. However, in contrast with the quasi-evolutionary way in which policy is thought of and conceptualised it seems that policy doing is still being guided by ‘market-failure’ justifications causing actual policies to remain narrow in their scope. In this paper we sidestep this analytical divide of thinking/doing by developing a co-evolutionary framework that utilises a more productive analytical divide of means/ends. That is to say we focus on a process of co-evolution of a higher-order, one which takes place ‘inside’ the agent of policy herself, and involves changes in the ways ‘means’ and ‘ends’ are understood and acted upon. Conceptualising policy problems in terms of means/ends contributes to current debates by rendering the difficulty that countries are facing in their attempts to prioritise biotechnology more intelligible and thus manageable.
Adopting numbering practices is central to ‘business-like’ public organising. These practices were primarily critiqued for their more-than-technical, normative character. This paper expands the critique of numbers in governance by considering numbers’ epistemic consequences in public sector work. Drawing on Whitehead’s philosophy of aesthetics and an ethnography of enumeration inside a public agency in England, the paper argues that enumeration techniques, when relying on accounting categories and used within a ‘business-like’ public sector, end up enacting knowledge objects that are aesthetic in kind. Numbered entities taken as performance evidence (metrics, rankings) end up (a) part of a project of enunciation, (b) opaque for conceptual interrogation, and (c) attuned to through bodily affect. Such characterisation makes two contributions. First, it conceptualises ‘aesthetic enumerated entities’ as a way of understanding instrumental knowledge in organising. Second, it extends our scope of engaging with the aesthetic by going beyond conceptualisations focused on art or beauty.
29 April 2025 in Journal of Organizational Ethnography
Purpose: This work contributes to organizational videography by proposing interactive videography as a methodological innovation that allows ethnographers to experience and theorize the relational dynamics of organizational life through interactive, emergent visualizations. Using SpacesGame, an interactive research artifact developed using Unreal Engine 4, the study advances the scope of expressive videography by integrating interactivity into the visual representation of theoretical concepts. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on Actor-Network Theory (ANT), it highlights how interactive 3D spaces as experimental apparatuses enable the exploration of complex theoretical constructs, such as the entanglement of agency within organizational processes. Findings: The paper elucidates how game engines can be leveraged to inscribe theoretical imagination in organizational research, demonstrating the contribution of real-time interactivity to expressive videography. In doing so, it argues that videography can better theorize the full sensory dimensions of organizational life through the utilization of interactivity, particularly when addressing complex and difficult-to-visualize theoretical constructs and relationships. Research limitations/implications: Although game development has been more accessible in recent years, these skills are still uncommon, and many researchers may find it prohibitively challenging to engage in this type of digital research. However, as generative AI tools become more user-friendly, the scope for adoption of this method is vastly growing. Originality/value: This, to the best of the author’s knowledge, is the first attempt at using game engine software for conceptual work in ethnographic research. It offers a way to present and engage theory within an interactive space that allows for novel engagement with theorizing, especially those pertaining to agency in organizational inquiries.