31 May 2023 in Nature Reviews Psychology
18 October 2021 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Despite the ever-growing economic gap between the very wealthy and the rest of the population, support for redistributive policies tends to be low. This research tested whether people’s tolerance of inequality differs when it is represented in terms of a successful individual versus a group of people at the top of the economic ladder. We propose that drawing people’s attention to wealthy individuals undermines support for redistribution by leading people to believe that the rich person’s wealth is well deserved. Across eight studies (n = 2,800), survey participants rated unequal distributions of resources as more fair when presented with an individual, rather than a group, at the top of the distribution. Participants also expressed lower support for redistributive policies after considering inequality represented by successful individuals compared to groups. This effect was driven by people’s different attributions for individual versus group success. Participants thought that individuals at the top were more deserving of their successes and, in turn, were less likely to support redistribution when inequality was represented by individual success. These findings suggest that support for inequality, and policies to reduce it, may depend on who people are led to consider when they think about the top of the economic distribution. Significance Economic inequality in the developed world has increased substantially over the past several decades. During the COVID-19 pandemic, billionaires saw their wealth increase while many people struggled to meet basic needs. Redistributive policies like wealth and inheritance taxes would reduce this inequality, but broad public support for these policies is elusive. This research finds that the wealth of successful individuals may reduce support for redistribution because people are more likely to believe that the wealth of individuals, rather than groups, at the top is well earned. These findings suggest that the way inequality is presented—with either groups or individuals at the top—affects people’s attributions for how wealth is earned and their tolerance of growing inequality.
17 September 2022 in Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy
1 November 2025 in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
The widely documented "outgroup homogeneity effect" refers to people's tendency to view members of groups to which they do not belong (outgroups) as more similar to one another than members of their own groups (ingroups). Here, we present evidence for a novel but related phenomenon: People tend to view members of different minority groups as collectively more similar to one another than members of the majority group are to one another. Across nine studies (and four studies reported in the Supplemental Materials), we demonstrate a robust "minority-groups homogeneity effect" among participants from both majority groups (Studies 1-5) and minority groups (Studies 6-8), albeit less consistently among the latter. We provide experimental support for the role of beliefs in the common fate of minorities in driving this effect: When participants are led to believe that minority groups do not share a common fate, they no longer rate them as more similar than the majority (Study 9). These studies shed light on a broad pattern of social perception that may influence how members of different groups interact with one another and how they respond to cultural and demographic changes in society. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).