Environmental and/or land-use planning with or for Indigenous peoples is not well studied. This is true for the First Nations in Canada as well. In this article, we review what literature exists with respect to environmental/land-use planning for Indigenous peoples and then review the types of land-use plans that First Nations in Canada have created on their own behalf. We conclude that planners, First Nations and governments need to turn greater attention to this understudied issue and advocate for the development of a field of Indigenous planning, which is planning created by Indigenous peoples to meet their own purposes and needs rather than pursuing planning done to First Nations.
Aboriginal peoples have distinct perspectives and relationships with the terrestrial and aquatic settings and components that sustain cultural modes of life. Valued components derived from these cultural understandings are to be incorporated into environmental impact assessments (EIA) that occur in their respective territories. Despite this technical and legal basis, Aboriginal cultures are often inadequately accounted for in many ex-post plans of development activities and projects. This paper examines changes made to the regulatory requirements of an ex-post plan that involved Aboriginal peoples and a pipeline project located in north-east British Columbia, Canada. The research context and the revisions made to the conventional practice are presented, followed by a discussion of the possible broader implications for future EIAs. The study provides useful insights into the deficiencies of conventional practices and contributes to technical understandings in terms of integrating and protecting Aboriginal cultures through ex-post plans.
Environmental impact assessment is viewed as an integral planning tool with respect to the sustainable development of land and natural resources, as it has the potential to protect the different values held by individuals and groups when done appropriately. This article examines an approach by the Environmental Assessment Office of British Columbia, Canada, regarding the scope of a cumulative effect assessment for the environmental assessment process of a proposed coal mine project that is endangering a threatened herd of caribou relied upon by West Moberly First Nations (an Indigenous group in Canada) for cultural subsistence. A Canadian-based equality framework is used to ground the environmental justice analysis. We conclude that the government's application of its discretionary powers in this case resulted the cultural values of West Moberly being given a diminished level of protection and benefit of the law in comparison to the social values held by mainstream society.
1 December 2018 in Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management