Should students in public schools learn to think critically about racial (in)justice and social (in)equity? The results of a recent mixed methods survey for educators revealed that a significant number of teachers did not believe they were responsible for helping their students develop the skills to critically analyze and respond to social injustice. Quantitative data showed that most of the educators who responded unfavorably, self-identified as “White” teachers of mostly White students; while most of the White teachers of mostly African American students held the opposite belief. Qualitative data provided some context for the rationales informing the divergent beliefs of these White teachers. Utilizing a combination of grounded theory and coding methods, I explore, illustrate, and analyze the responses of both sets of White teachers in an effort to illuminate and contextualize their articulated beliefs. Then, I interrogate the findings in light of their emergence along racial strata, using insights from scholarship in Critical Whiteness Studies and Critical Literacy/Pedagogy. Then I discuss their implications with reference to Robert Starratt’s “Virtue of Responsibility” and current theories of antiracist education. I conclude with a call for improving the educational experiences and societal outcomes of all students by naming and disrupting social illiteracy, championing critical-ethical literacy and encouraging an antiracist ethos.
This paper explores what educators articulated and perceived about their knowledge, beliefs, and mindsets (KBMs) to engage in racial equity practices aimed at closing opportunity gaps in their schools. Our research team utilized cognitive interviews (Drennan in J Adv Nurs 42:57–63, 2003) to gain insight into the educators’ KBMs about racial equity in their roles as teachers, school leaders, and aspiring school leaders. The data collected and analyzed from the cognitive interviews are part of a larger, multi-phase project designed to develop and validate a survey instrument to assess educators’ perceived KBMs regarding racial equity. In this paper, we focused on six educators who participated in the study. Their roles included school leaders, teachers, and aspiring school leaders working in urban schools. The findings suggest discrepancies in the educators’ preparation programs, which influenced how the educators engaged and negotiated racial equity practices in their classrooms. Additionally, participants discussed how their identities, their students’ identities, and various contextual factors shaped their practices. Lastly, we discuss the implications for teachers, school leaders, and program coordinators of educator preparation programs.