Cristina Bicchieri’s Social Norm Theory presents a detailed behavioral account of how social expectations shape individual decisions and, consequently, can generate desirable collective patterns such as saving energy. Agent-based models (ABMs) have become a commonly used tool for studying how these micro-level decisions generate macro-level norm dynamics. However, translating social science theories into ABMs typically requires substantial interpretation of the theory as well as consideration of the application context. As a result, existing translations may differ in their formalizations, vary widely across disciplines, and yield diverging simulation outcomes. Therefore, we conducted a qualitative systematic literature review (not registered, given its exploratory nature), screening 878 publications extracted from Scopus and Google Scholar, to identify and compare options for how Bicchieri’s theory can be formalized in ABMs. In this process, we examined formalization options of core concepts of Bicchieri’s theory (i.e., reference networks, social expectations, personal normative beliefs, and norm sensitivity) as well as agents’ decision-making. Across the identified 24 publications – focusing on studies explicitly referencing Bicchieri’s work – we synthesized and documented recurring patterns in formalization options alongside substantial variation. Because standard risk-of-bias tools are not designed for qualitative synthesis of formalization choices, we adapted an approach informed by Cochrane RoB 2 and ROBIS to assess our main findings, confirming that our main outcomes remain largely robust. Our results offer a structured catalog of formalization options that modelers can reuse and combine when implementing Bicchieri’s theory. We also identify several avenues for future research, including opportunities to advance empirical calibration practices. To strengthen cross-study comparability and foster cumulative model development, we suggest improving the traceability between theoretical constructs and formalizations, along with promoting greater reuse of proven formalizations.